HRV and Stress: A Mixed-Methods Approach for Comparison of Wearable Heart Rate Sensors for Biofeedback

ВСР и стресс: смешанный методический подход к сравнению носимых датчиков частоты сердечных сокращений для биологической обратной связи
Cem Ersoy, Corina Sas, Muhammad Umair, Niaz Chalabianloo
2021-01-01

biofeedbackheart rate variabilitymixed-methods approachphotoplethysmographywearable heart rate sensors
Stress is one of the most significant health problems in today's world. Existing work has used heart rate variability (HRV) to detect stress and provide biofeedback in order to regulate it. There has been a growing interest in using wearable biosensors to measure HRV. Each of these sensors acquires heart rate data using different technologies for various bodily locations, therefore posing a challenge for researchers to decide upon a particular device in a research experiment. Previous work has only compared different sensing devices against a gold standard in terms of data quality, thus overlooking qualitative analysis for the usability and acceptability of such devices. This paper introduces a mixed-methods approach to compare the data quality and user acceptance of the six most common wearable heart rate monitoring biosensors. We conducted a 70-minute data collection procedure to obtain HRV data from 32 participants followed by a 10-minute semi-structured interview on sensors' wearability and comfort, long-term use, aesthetics, and social acceptance. We performed quantitative analysis consisting of correlation and agreement analysis on the HRV data and thematic analysis on qualitative data obtained from interviews. Our results show that the electrocardiography (ECG) chest strap achieved the highest correlation and agreement levels in all sessions and had the lowest amount of artifacts, followed by the photoplethysmography (PPG) wristband, ECG sensor board kit and PPG smartwatch. In all three sessions, wrist-worn devices showed a lower amount of agreement and correlation with the reference device. Qualitative findings from interviews highlight that participants prefer wrist and arm-worn devices in terms of aesthetics, wearability, and comfort, followed by chest-worn devices. Moreover, participants mentioned that the latter are more likely to invite social judgment from others, and they would not want to wear it in public. Participants preferred the chest strap for short-term use and the wrist and arm-worn sensors over long-time.
1
Data were collected from 32 participants during a 70-minute procedure, followed by interviews addressing wearability, comfort, long-term use, aesthetics, and social acceptance.
2
Participants preferred wrist- and arm-worn devices for aesthetics, wearability, and comfort, whereas chest-worn devices were viewed as more socially stigmatizing and unsuitable for public use.
3
The ECG chest strap showed the highest HRV correlation and agreement across all sessions and produced the fewest artifacts.
4
The PPG wristband ranked second in data quality, followed by the ECG sensor board kit and PPG smartwatch; wrist-worn devices generally agreed less with the reference sensor.
5
The paper introduces a mixed-methods framework combining HRV data quality and user-acceptance assessments for comparing six wearable heart-rate sensors.

Wearable heart rate monitoring biosensors used to measure HRV

Comparative data quality, usability, comfort, wearability, aesthetics, and social acceptance of wearable heart rate sensors for HRV-based biofeedback

Publication Details
Publication Date
2021-01-01
Journal
Publisher
ISSN
Cited by
126
Access Type
Author Information
Authors
Cem Ersoy
Corina Sas
Muhammad Umair
Niaz Chalabianloo
Explore further
Open the scid.ai AI chat with a ready-made request: it will find papers on a similar topic and help build a literature review.
Find similar papers in the chat →
Make a presentation
100%