Review Article_Specific Learning Disability Assessment and Interpretation: NIMHANS SLD Battery and Beyond
Обзорная статья: Оценка и интерпретация специфических нарушений обучаемости (SLD): батарея NIMHANS и далее
2021-03-30
SCID: 54.1/26np4sad
Discuss with AI
NIMHANS Specific Learning Disability BatterySLD diagnosis criteriaSpecific Learning Disability assessmentassessment interpretation challengeseducational grade range
Figures from the paper
Abstract (AI)
To diagnose Specific Learning Disability (SLD) in India, only 'NIMHANS Specific Learning Disability Battery (NSB)' is accepted for assessment and certification of disability. Earlier editions of the NSB used 'functioning at three standards below the current class of the child' to arrive at a diagnosis of SLD, and was simple to administer and interpret. Given these, majority of psychologists used it in their routine assessments, and in most of the cases, it was relatively easy to diagnose SLD with this battery. A major limitation faced when using the NSB was that it had test items only till the 7th grade. In the updated NSB, there are test items till the 10th grade, which is definitely a big upgrade. However, as the battery is relatively concise and does not clearly describe the nuances of assessment and interpretation in marginal and complex scenarios, some young psychologists and research scholars might find it difficult to diagnose SLD. Some of these scenarios are, when the child shows problems in academics but does not exactly fulfil the NSB criteria; when the child is having problems with second language instead of the first language; when the child is from an international curriculum; when the child is studying in a class higher than grade 10; when comprehension appears to be impaired; and/or the issue of whether or not to have so many subtypes of SLD. This article highlights some of these issues, discusses and attempts to provide possible solutions with respect to assessment and interpretation.
Key Findings
1
A key limitation of the older NSB was test items only up to 7th grade; the updated NSB extends items to 10th grade, improving coverage.
2
Earlier NSB editions diagnosed SLD using the criterion 'functioning at three standards below current class', which made administration and interpretation simple and facilitated widespread clinical use.
3
In India, the NIMHANS Specific Learning Disability Battery (NSB) is the only accepted tool for SLD assessment and certification.
4
The article identifies challenging scenarios not well-handled by NSB—problems not meeting NSB criteria, second-language difficulties, international curricula, classes above grade 10, impaired comprehension, and questions about numerous SLD subtypes—and proposes assessment and interpretation solutions.
5
The updated NSB remains concise and lacks clear guidance for assessing and interpreting marginal or complex cases, posing difficulties for less-experienced psychologists and researchers.
Research Object
NIMHANS Specific Learning Disability Battery (NSB) and its use in diagnosing Specific Learning Disability in Indian children
Research Subject
Challenges, nuances, and proposed solutions for assessment and interpretation of Specific Learning Disability using the NSB (including limitations across grades, marginal/complex cases, language and curriculum differences, comprehension issues, and SLD subtyping)
Publication Details
Publication Date
2021-03-30
Journal
Publisher
ISSN
Cited by
6
Open access PDF
Access Type
Author Information
Download PDF
Subscribe to digest