Understanding What Shapes a Polycentric Governance System

Понимание факторов, формирующих полицентрическую систему управления
Ramiro Berardo, Mark N. Lubell
2016-03-09

bonding structuresbridging structuresinstitutional strengthpolycentric governancerisk hypothesis
Abstract Recent research has shown that communication networks involving governmental and nongovernmental actors self‐organize based on how risk is perceived. According to the “risk hypothesis,” actors embedded in governance systems in which there is widespread risk of defection tend to form bonding structures, whereas those in low‐risk systems form bridging structures. A parallel strand of research proposes to study complex governance systems composed of multiple actors and the decision‐making forums in which they interact. In this article, the authors couple these research threads and show how bonding and bridging structures form when stakeholders participate in three complex governance systems of varying institutional strength. Findings suggest that the prevalence of one type of structure over the other depends on contextual variables such as the stability of the institutions and the occurrence of environmental focusing events that demand quick policy responses .
1
Across three governance systems with varying institutional strength, bonding and bridging structures emerged in different patterns.
2
Communication networks among governmental and nongovernmental actors self-organize partly according to perceived defection risk.
3
High-risk governance environments tend to produce bonding structures, whereas low-risk environments tend to produce bridging structures.
4
The dominance of bonding versus bridging depends on contextual factors, including institutional stability and environmental focusing events requiring rapid policy responses.
5
The study links risk-based network formation with polycentric governance systems involving multiple actors and decision-making forums.

Three polycentric governance systems involving governmental and nongovernmental stakeholders and their decision-making forums

The formation and prevalence of bonding versus bridging communication structures as shaped by institutional stability and environmental focusing events

Publication Details
Publication Date
2016-03-09
Journal
Public Administration Review
Publisher
Wiley
ISSN
0033-3352
Cited by
252
Access Type
Author Information
Authors
Ramiro Berardo
Mark N. Lubell
Explore further
Open the scid.ai AI chat with a ready-made request: it will find papers on a similar topic and help build a literature review.
Find similar papers in the chat →
Make a presentation
100%