Did Alexander the Great Discover America? Debating Space and Time in Renaissance Istanbul
Открыл ли Александр Великий Америку? Дискуссии о пространстве и времени в ренессансном Стамбуле
2019-09-01
SCID: 54.1/2qnpskw2
Discuss with AI
Alexander the Great and America hypothesisOttoman debates on the AmericasRenaissance Istanbul intellectual historysixteenth-century Ottoman writings
Figures from the paper
Abstract (AI)
Following the first European voyages of exploration to the New World, several Ottoman authors debated whether Alexander the Great may have already known of the American continent in classical antiquity. By exploring the contours of this previously unstudied intra-Ottoman debate, the present article challenges the prevailing scholarly view that sixteenth-century Ottoman writings about the Americas were at best frivolous and at worst incoherent. Instead, these texts engaged with many of the same questions provoked by the discoveries in contemporary Europe, while at the same time intersecting with the most profound and contested concerns of Ottoman statecraft.
Key Findings
1
Contrary to prevailing scholarship, Ottoman writings on the Americas were neither merely frivolous nor incoherent.
2
Discussions of the Americas in Ottoman writings intersected with significant and contested concerns of Ottoman statecraft.
3
Ottoman texts engaged with many of the same questions raised in contemporary Europe by New World discoveries.
4
Sixteenth-century Ottoman authors debated whether Alexander the Great knew of the American continent in antiquity.
5
This intra-Ottoman debate about American discovery has been previously unstudied.
Research Object
Sixteenth-century Ottoman writings and intra-Ottoman debate concerning whether Alexander the Great knew of the Americas
Research Subject
How these Ottoman texts debated space and time—specifically arguments about Alexander's prior knowledge of the American continent—and how those debates related to contemporary European questions and Ottoman statecraft concerns
Publication Details
Publication Date
2019-09-01
Journal
Publisher
ISSN
Access Type
Author Information
Download PDF
Subscribe to digest