The Lived Experiences of Migrants in Detention

Жизненный опыт мигрантов в условиях содержания под стражей
Ine Lietaert, Eric Broekaert, Ilse Derluyn
2014-06-04

deportationimmigration detentionlegal belongingmigrant lived experiencesmigrants' wellbeing
Abstract The detention and deportation of (undocumented) non‐citizens has become one of the political priorities in the realisation of states' internal migration control. The increase in detention and deportation of migrants raises questions about these practices' implicit functions and their impact on the migrants subjected to detention. This paper aims to contribute to our understanding of the contemporary expansion of immigration detention by focusing on detained migrants' lived experiences and perspectives on detention practices. On the basis of interviews with 31 detainees in Belgian detention centres, we explore how migrants' self‐perceptions relate to current legal and societal discourses. By referring to their connections with the host country through material, familial or emotional ties, the interviewees strongly oppose their detention and upcoming deportation. Thereby, they bring the (contested) experience of belonging firmly to the centre of this paper, referring to the connection between ‘body’ and ‘place’. They also point to the large and growing gap between their lived experiences on the one hand and the realities and political discourses of (legal) belonging on the other. In addition, detainees' lived experiences shed light onto the burden and consequences of lacking citizenship, and, simultaneously, demonstrate how individuals try to assert alternative, identity‐based claims, and/or deny – or at least avoid – the idea of deportation. We hereby hypothesise that this denial, as also the growing gap between detainees' own perspectives and policy and public discourses might have a major impact on migrants' wellbeing and their reintegration processes back ‘home’. Copyright © 2014 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.
1
Detainees’ accounts place contested belonging at the centre of detention experiences, linking embodied identities and personal connections to place.
2
Interviews with 31 detainees in Belgian detention centres show that migrants strongly oppose detention and deportation through material, familial, and emotional ties to the host country.
3
Lacking citizenship imposes significant burdens, while detainees assert alternative identity-based claims and deny or avoid the prospect of deportation.
4
The authors hypothesize that denial of deportation and the gap between lived experience and public policy may negatively affect wellbeing and reintegration after return.
5
The study identifies a widening gap between migrants’ lived experiences and legal or political definitions of belonging and citizenship.

Undocumented migrants detained in Belgian detention centres

Detainees’ lived experiences and perspectives on detention, deportation, belonging, and the consequences of lacking citizenship

Publication Details
Publication Date
2014-06-04
Journal
Publisher
ISSN
Access Type
Author Information
Authors
Ine Lietaert
Eric Broekaert
Ilse Derluyn
Explore further
Open the scid.ai AI chat with a ready-made request: it will find papers on a similar topic and help build a literature review.
Find similar papers in the chat
Make a presentation
100%