Review and meta-analysis of recent life cycle assessments of hydrogen production

Обзор и метаанализ современных оценок жизненного цикла производства водорода
Marcelle C. McManus, Timothy J. Mays, Julian Wilkinson
2023-04-10

global warming potentialhydrogen productionlife cycle assessmentlow-GWP scenariosmeta-analysis
The world is facing an urgent global climate challenge, and hydrogen (H2) is increasingly valued as a carbon-free energy carrier that can play a prominent role in decarbonising economies. However, the environmental impact of the different methods for hydrogen production are sometimes overlooked. This work provides a comprehensive overview of the environmental impacts and costs of a diverse range of methods for producing hydrogen. Ninety-nine life cycle assessments (LCAs) of hydrogen production published between 2015 and 2022 are categorised by geography, production method, energy source, goal and scope, and compared by data sources and methodology. A meta-analysis of methodological choices is used to identify a subset of mutually comparable studies whose results are then compared, initially by global warming potential (GWP), then low-GWP scenarios are compared by other indicators. The results show that the lowest GWP is achieved by methods that are currently more expensive (∼US $4–9/kg H2) compared to the dominant methods of producing hydrogen from fossil fuels (∼US $1–2/kg H2). The research finds that data are currently limited for comparing environmental indicators other than GWP, such as terrestrial acidification or freshwater eutrophication. Recommendations are made for future LCAs of hydrogen production.
1
A meta-analysis identifies mutually comparable studies and compares hydrogen-production pathways first by global warming potential, then by additional environmental indicators.
2
Available evidence is insufficient to robustly compare indicators beyond global warming potential, including terrestrial acidification and freshwater eutrophication; the review recommends improved future LCAs.
3
The lowest-global-warming-potential hydrogen pathways are currently more expensive, costing approximately US$4–9/kg H2 versus US$1–2/kg H2 for dominant fossil-fuel-based production.
4
The review analyses 99 life cycle assessments of hydrogen production published between 2015 and 2022.
5
The studies are systematically compared by geography, production method, energy source, goal and scope, data sources, and methodology.

Hydrogen production methods and their life cycle environmental performance

Comparative environmental impacts, costs, and methodological variability of hydrogen production pathways, with emphasis on global warming potential and other life-cycle indicators

Publication Details
Publication Date
2023-04-10
Journal
Publisher
ISSN
Cited by
101
Access Type
Author Information
Authors
Marcelle C. McManus
Timothy J. Mays
Julian Wilkinson
Explore further
Open the scid.ai AI chat with a ready-made request: it will find papers on a similar topic and help build a literature review.
Find similar papers in the chat →
Make a presentation
100%