Assessing the Probability That a Positive Report is False: An Approach for Molecular Epidemiology Studies

Оценка вероятности того, что положительный результат является ложным: подход для исследований в области молекулярной эпидемиологии
Nathaniel Rothman, Stephen Jacob Chanock, Laure K. El ghormli, Montserrat García‐Closas, Sholom Wacholder
2004-03-16

false positive report probabilitygenetic variantsmolecular epidemiologyprior probabilitystatistical power
Too many reports of associations between genetic variants and common cancer sites and other complex diseases are false positives. A major reason for this unfortunate situation is the strategy of declaring statistical significance based on a P value alone, particularly, any P value below.05. The false positive report probability (FPRP), the probability of no true association between a genetic variant and disease given a statistically significant finding, depends not only on the observed P value but also on both the prior probability that the association between the genetic variant and the disease is real and the statistical power of the test. In this commentary, we show how to assess the FPRP and how to use it to decide whether a finding is deserving of attention or "noteworthy." We show how this approach can lead to improvements in the design, analysis, and interpretation of molecular epidemiology studies. Our proposal can help investigators, editors, and readers of research articles to protect themselves from overinterpreting statistically significant findings that are not likely to signify a true association. An FPRP-based criterion for deciding whether to call a finding noteworthy formalizes the process already used informally by investigators--that is, tempering enthusiasm for remarkable study findings with considerations of plausibility.
1
An FPRP-based noteworthy criterion formalizes the practice of tempering enthusiasm for remarkable results with biological and epidemiological plausibility.
2
Applying FPRP can improve the design, analysis, and interpretation of studies by reducing overinterpretation of statistically significant but implausible findings.
3
FPRP depends on the observed P value, the prior probability that the association is genuine, and the statistical power of the test.
4
False positive report probability (FPRP) estimates the probability that a statistically significant genetic association is not real.
5
The paper presents an approach for assessing FPRP and using it to determine whether molecular epidemiology findings are sufficiently noteworthy.

Associations between genetic variants and common cancer sites and other complex diseases in molecular epidemiology studies

Assessment of the false positive report probability (FPRP) using the observed P value, prior probability of a true association, and statistical power to determine whether statistically significant genetic variant–disease findings are noteworthy

Publication Details
Publication Date
2004-03-16
Journal
Publisher
ISSN
Cited by
1743
Access Type
Author Information
Authors
Nathaniel Rothman
Stephen Jacob Chanock
Laure K. El ghormli
Montserrat García‐Closas
Sholom Wacholder
Explore further
Open the scid.ai AI chat with a ready-made request: it will find papers on a similar topic and help build a literature review.
Find similar papers in the chat →
Make a presentation
100%