War and State Formation in Ancient China and Early Modern Europe
Война и формирование государства в Древнем Китае и Европе раннего Нового времени
2005-07-04
SCID: 54.1/4a4254ub
Discuss with AI
ancient Chinacomparative historical analysisearly modern Europesovereign territorial stateswar and state formation
Figures from the paper
Abstract (AI)
The Eurocentric conventional wisdom holds that the West is unique in having a multi-state system in international relations and liberal democracy in state-society relations. At the same time, the Sinocentric perspective believes that China is destined to have authoritarian rule under a unified empire. In fact, China in the Spring and Autumn and Warring States periods (656–221 BC) was once a system of sovereign territorial states similar to Europe in the early modern period. Both cases witnessed the prevalence of war, formation of alliances, development of the centralized bureaucracy, emergence of citizenship rights, and expansion of international trade. This book, first published in 2005, examines why China and Europe shared similar processes but experienced opposite outcomes. This historical comparison of China and Europe challenges the presumption that Europe was destined to enjoy checks and balances while China was preordained to suffer under a coercive universal status.
Key Findings
1
Ancient China during the Spring and Autumn and Warring States periods formed a sovereign territorial-state system comparable to early modern Europe.
2
China and early modern Europe experienced similar processes, including warfare, alliance formation, centralized bureaucracy, citizenship rights, and expanding international trade.
3
Despite these shared developments, China and Europe ultimately produced opposite political outcomes in state organization and state–society relations.
4
The comparison challenges the view that Europe was destined for checks and balances while China was inherently destined for coercive universal empire.
5
The study rejects both Eurocentric and Sinocentric assumptions by explaining divergent outcomes through historical comparison rather than civilizational predestination.
Research Object
Political development processes in ancient China (Spring and Autumn and Warring States periods) and early modern Europe
Research Subject
The divergent political outcomes of similar processes of warfare, alliance formation, bureaucratic centralization, citizenship-rights development, and international trade in China and Europe
Publication Details
Publication Date
2005-07-04
Journal
Publisher
ISSN
Cited by
657
Access Type
Author Information
Download PDF
Subscribe to digest