Qualitative research methods

Методы качественного исследования
Shoshanna Sofaer
2002-08-01

cognitive interviewsfocus groupshealth care qualityqualitative research methodsquality improvement
The use of rigorous qualitative research methods can enhance the development of quality measures, the development and dissemination of comparative quality reports, as well as quality improvement efforts. This paper describes how such methods have been and can be used, and identifies how to improve the use of such methods in studying quality of care. Focus groups and cognitive interviews are now a standard part of the development of valid and reliable survey instruments. They are particularly useful in developing surveys to gather data on the experiences and responses of patients and consumers to plans, services, and providers. These two methods have also been adapted and applied to improve the development and dissemination of comparative quality reports to consumers and other audiences, while key informant interviews and focus groups have been critical in the exploratory assessment of stakeholder responses to reports and their effects on consumers. Interviews have also been used to identify best practices found in health plans receiving high scores on the Consumer Assessment of Health Plans Surveys and measures of effectiveness in the Health Employer Data and Information Set. It would be valuable to widen the use of qualitative methods, especially structured observations, to document in detail the delivery of services designed to improve quality, so the implementation of complex processes can be more carefully measured and related to outcomes. The design and conduct of rigorous qualitative research takes a skilled and experienced team. Issues commonly faced in quantitative work must also be addressed in qualitative studies, including study design, specification of the unit of analysis, sampling, instrument design and administration, and, in particular, data analysis. It is especially critical that the analysis and interpretation process be deliberate and thorough to avoid the use of initial impression rather than detailed examination of the raw data.
1
Expanded use of structured observation could document service delivery more precisely, enabling better measurement of complex-process implementation and its relationship to outcomes.
2
Focus groups and cognitive interviews are standard tools for developing valid, reliable surveys of patients’ and consumers’ experiences with plans, services, and providers.
3
Focus groups and key informant interviews support the development and dissemination of comparative quality reports and assessment of stakeholder and consumer responses.
4
Interviews can identify best practices among health plans with high Consumer Assessment of Health Plans Survey scores and strong Health Employer Data and Information Set effectiveness measures.
5
Reliable qualitative research requires experienced teams and rigorous attention to study design, sampling, instruments, analysis, and interpretation; detailed data examination is essential to avoid impressionistic conclusions.
6
Rigorous qualitative methods can strengthen quality-measure development, comparative quality reporting, and quality-improvement initiatives.

The use of qualitative research methods in studying health-care quality, including quality measures, comparative quality reports, quality-improvement efforts, and patient/consumer experiences of plans, services, and providers

The applications, contributions, and methodological requirements of rigorous qualitative methods for developing, disseminating, evaluating, and improving health-care quality measurement and improvement

Publication Details
Publication Date
2002-08-01
Journal
Publisher
ISSN
Cited by
346
Access Type
Author Information
Authors
Shoshanna Sofaer
Explore further
Open the scid.ai AI chat with a ready-made request: it will find papers on a similar topic and help build a literature review.
Find similar papers in the chat →
Make a presentation
100%