Judgment of information quality and cognitive authority in the Web

Оценка качества информации и когнитивного авторитета в Интернете
Soo Young Rieh
2001-12-14

Web searching behaviorcognitive authorityevaluative judgmentinformation qualitypredictive judgment
Abstract In the Web, making judgments of information quality and authority is a difficult task for most users because overall, there is no quality control mechanism. This study examines the problem of the judgment of information quality and cognitive authority by observing people's searching behavior in the Web. Its purpose is to understand the various factors that influence people's judgment of quality and authority in the Web, and the effects of those judgments on selection behaviors. Fifteen scholars from diverse disciplines participated, and data were collected combining verbal protocols during the searches, search logs, and postsearch interviews. It was found that the subjects made two distinct kinds of judgment: predictive judgment, and evaluative judgment. The factors influencing each judgment of quality and authority were identified in terms of characteristics of information objects, characteristics of sources, knowledge, situation, ranking in search output, and general assumption. Implications for Web design that will effectively support people's judgments of quality and authority are also discussed.
1
Findings were derived from verbal protocols, search logs, and postsearch interviews involving 15 scholars from diverse disciplines, informing Web-design implications.
2
Judgments of information quality and authority were influenced by information-object characteristics, source characteristics, users’ knowledge, search situations, result ranking, and general assumptions.
3
The study identified two distinct judgment types during Web searches: predictive judgments and evaluative judgments.
4
These quality and authority judgments affected users’ information-selection behaviors during searching.
5
Web users face difficulty judging information quality and cognitive authority because the Web lacks an overall quality-control mechanism.

People's information-searching behavior on the Web

Factors influencing judgments of information quality and cognitive authority, and the effects of those judgments on information selection behavior

Publication Details
Publication Date
2001-12-14
Journal
Publisher
ISSN
Cited by
612
Access Type
Author Information
Authors
Soo Young Rieh
Explore further
Open the scid.ai AI chat with a ready-made request: it will find papers on a similar topic and help build a literature review.
Find similar papers in the chat →
Make a presentation
100%