MENDELEEV EPONYMS IN THE EPOCH OF EDUCATIONAL ETHNOCENTRISM
Эпонимы Менделеева в эпоху образовательного этноцентризма
2023-06-12
SCID: 54.1/4eyyjthp
Discuss with AI
Mendeleev eponymschemical educationeducational ethnocentrismperiodic systemperiodic table
Figures from the paper
Abstract (AI)
Eponymous terms play an important role in STEM education. This research focuses on the current state of Mendeleev eponyms in the context of education and ethnocentrism, addressing their usage in various languages, their educational value, cases of questioned priority and copyright violation in Mendeleev major eponyms–periodic table and periodic system. 106 chemistry textbooks in 4 languages including Soviet-time and current Russian textbooks were perused to identify and trace Mendeleev eponyms over 1924-2016. Advanced Google Search with queries in Belarusian, English, Latvian, Polish, Russian, and Ukrainian was conducted to evaluate online presence of eponyms “Mendeleev periodic table” and “Mendeleev periodic system.” It was found that while Mendeleev eponyms occur generously on the Internet, periodic table and system with Mendeleev’s name attached are seldom used on non-Russian webpages. Most Mendeleev eponyms were made up in the USSR and remain popular and Russia, which can be explained within the framework of ethnocentrism as a ruling tendency. Recognizing Mendeleev’s priority, Flinn and Ross’s periodic systems can be considered plagiarized; a few factors might favor their emergence, but ethnocentrism is unlikely to be one of them. Mendeleev eponyms remain valuable assets for science education, acting as shortcuts to the history of science and actualizing interdisciplinary connections. Keywords: chemical education, eponym, ethnocentrism, Mendeleev, periodic table, periodic system
Key Findings
1
Mendeleev eponyms are widespread online, but the “Mendeleev periodic table” and “Mendeleev periodic system” are rarely used on non-Russian webpages.
2
Mendeleev eponyms remain valuable educational tools because they provide concise links to the history of science and promote interdisciplinary connections.
3
Most Mendeleev eponyms originated in the USSR and remain especially popular in Russia, consistent with educational ethnocentrism as a prevailing influence.
4
Recognizing Mendeleev’s priority, the authors argue that Flinn’s and Ross’s periodic systems can be regarded as plagiarized, although ethnocentrism is unlikely to explain their emergence.
5
The study analyzed 106 chemistry textbooks in four languages from 1924–2016 to trace the use of Mendeleev eponyms.
Research Object
Mendeleev eponyms in chemistry education, especially the Mendeleev periodic table and periodic system
Research Subject
The linguistic usage, educational value, historical priority, and ethnocentric distribution of Mendeleev eponyms across textbooks and online sources
Publication Details
Publication Date
2023-06-12
Journal
Publisher
ISSN
Cited by
3
Open access PDF
Access Type
Author Information
Download PDF
Subscribe to digest