Therapeutic Indices of Topical Antiseptics in Wound Care: A Systematic Review
Терапевтические индексы местных антисептиков при лечении ран: систематический обзор
2024-10-02
SCID: 54.1/4s66828r
Discuss with AI
chronic woundsmammalian cell cytotoxicityminimum bactericidal concentrationtherapeutic indextopical antiseptics
Figures from the paper
Abstract (AI)
ABSTRACT GENERAL PURPOSE To review the therapeutic indices of topical antiseptics for bacterial species commonly isolated from chronic wounds. TARGET AUDIENCE This continuing education activity is intended for physicians, physician assistants, nurse practitioners, and registered nurses with an interest in skin and wound care. LEARNING OBJECTIVES/OUTCOMES After participating in this educational activity, the participant will: 1. Explain the mechanisms underlying chronic wound physiology and their implications for effective wound healing and management. 2. Evaluate the role of therapeutic index values for topical antiseptics in chronic wound management. 3. Apply evidence-based treatment strategies for chronic wound management. BACKGROUND Chronic wounds place a heavy burden on healthcare systems and reduce patients’ activities of daily living. Increased bacterial bioburden (local infection, covert infection) impairs wound healing. With increased antimicrobial resistance, alternative antimicrobial strategies are important. OBJECTIVE To determine the topical antiseptic therapeutic index values for common wound bacterial species. The therapeutic index is a ratio comparing lowest concentration that causes mammalian cell cytotoxicity to the minimum bactericidal concentration; higher values indicate greater safety / clinical benefit. DATA SOURCES MEDLINE and EMBASE databases were searched from conception to June 2023. Common wound bacterial species and their in-vitro minimum bactericidal concentrations were compared to the minimum mammalian cell cytotoxicity concentration. STUDY SELECTION The authors identified 37 qualifying articles. DATA EXTRACTION Antiseptic, bacterial organism, mammalian cell type, minimum bactericidal concentration, and mammalian cell cytotoxicity concentration values. DATA SYNTHESIS The therapeutic indices for the topical antiseptics were generally low, with most ranging between 0.5 and 3.0. The highest therapeutic index values for Escherichia coli (5.49), Staphylococcus aureus (6.31) and Pseudomonas aeruginosa (8.81) were achieved by hypochlorous acid. The highest therapeutic index value for methicillin resistant S aureus (12.1) was achieved by polyhexamethylene biguanide. CONCLUSIONS Antibiotic stewardship principles need to be applied to topical antiseptics due to some isolated topical antiseptic resistance and cross-resistance to oral antimicrobials. The choice of antiseptic should not be made solely based on therapeutic index values but individualized with the wound healing condition including covert infection.
Key Findings
1
MEDLINE and EMBASE searches through June 2023 identified 37 qualifying articles reporting bactericidal and mammalian-cell cytotoxicity concentrations.
2
The abstract indicates that therapeutic index values differed among topical antiseptics and bacterial organisms, but the reported excerpt does not provide the specific highest values for Escherichia coli or other species.
3
The therapeutic index compares the lowest mammalian-cell cytotoxicity concentration with the minimum bactericidal concentration; higher values indicate greater potential safety and clinical benefit.
4
Therapeutic indices were generally low, with most antiseptics ranging from 0.5 to 3.0, indicating limited safety margins between antimicrobial activity and mammalian-cell toxicity.
5
This systematic review evaluated therapeutic indices of topical antiseptics against bacterial species commonly isolated from chronic wounds.
Research Object
topical antiseptics used in chronic wound care against common wound bacterial species
Research Subject
therapeutic index values, comparing mammalian cell cytotoxicity concentrations with minimum bactericidal concentrations, as an indicator of antiseptic safety and clinical benefit
Publication Details
Publication Date
2024-10-02
Journal
Publisher
ISSN
Access Type
Author Information
Download PDF
Subscribe to digest