A Comparative Analysis of Western and Russian Reputation Models in the XXI century
Сравнительный анализ западных и российских моделей репутации в XXI веке
2026-01-13
SCID: 54.1/52z884ux
Discuss with AI
Russian reputation modelWestern reputation modelalgorithmic trust managementinformal institution of trustsocial capital
Figures from the paper
Abstract (AI)
This article provides a comparative analysis of Western and Russian reputation models within the context of sociological and institutional-economic approaches. Reputation is viewed as a form of social capital and an informal institution of trust that ensures the predictability of social interactions and reduces potential costs in human interactions. It is revealed that the Western reputation model is based on centuries-old experience combining the institution of law, market competition, and individual responsibility, making it more universal and formalized. The Russian model is more situational and personalized, based on informal connections, group loyalty, and political and cultural conditions. This article also analyzes the transformation of reputation mechanisms in the digital age, in which reputation is becoming an element of algorithmic trust management. A conclusion is drawn regarding the difference between institutionalized trust of the Western type and adaptive, contextual loyalty, more characteristic of the Russian model.
Key Findings
1
In the digital age reputation mechanisms transform toward algorithmic trust management, making reputation an element of algorithmic control.
2
Reputation functions as social capital and an informal institution of trust that ensures predictability of social interactions and reduces transaction costs.
3
Russian reputation model is situational and personalized, relying on informal connections, group loyalty, and specific political and cultural conditions.
4
There is a fundamental difference between Western institutionalized trust and Russian adaptive, contextual loyalty.
5
Western reputation model is based on long-standing combination of law, market competition, and individual responsibility, making it more universal and formalized.
Research Object
Western and Russian reputation models
Research Subject
Comparative differences in the foundations, mechanisms, and transformations of these reputation models—specifically institutionalization (law, market, individual responsibility) versus situational/personalized informal mechanisms (connections, group loyalty, political/cultural factors), and their evolution in the digital/algorithmic age
Publication Details
Publication Date
2026-01-13
Journal
Publisher
ISSN
Cited by
1
Open access PDF
Access Type
Author Information
Download PDF
Subscribe to digest