The Effects of Problem-Based, Project-Based, and Case-Based Learning on Students’ Motivation: a Meta-Analysis

Влияние проблемно-ориентированного, проектно-ориентированного и кейс-ориентированного обучения на мотивацию студентов: метаанализ
Lidia R. Arends, Lisette Wijnia, Remy M. J. P. Rikers, Sofie M. M. Loyens, Gera Noordzij
2024-02-28

case-based learningmeta-analysisproblem-based learningproject-based learningstudent motivation
Abstract In this meta-analysis, we examined the effects on students’ motivation of student-centered, problem-driven learning methods compared to teacher-centered/lecture-based learning. Specifically, we considered problem-based (PBL), project-based (PjBL), and case-based learning (CBL). We viewed motivation as a multifaceted construct consisting of students’ beliefs (competence and control beliefs), perceptions of task value (interest and importance), and reasons for engaging in tasks (intrinsic or extrinsic). In addition, we included students’ attitudes toward school subjects (e.g., science). We included 139 subsamples from the 132 included reports (83 PBL, 37 PjBL, and 19 CBL subsamples). Overall, PBL, PjBL, and CBL had a small to moderate, heterogeneous positive effect ( d = 0.498) on motivation. Moderator analyses revealed that larger effect sizes were found for students’ beliefs, values, and attitudes compared to students’ reasons for studying. No differences were found between the three instructional methods on motivation. However, effect sizes were larger when problem-driven learning was applied in a single course (when compared to a curriculum-level approach). Larger effects were also found in some academic domains (i.e., healthcare and STEM) than in others. While the impact of problem-driven learning on motivation is generally positive, the intricate interplay of factors such as academic domain and implementation level underscores the need for a nuanced approach to leveraging these instructional methods effectively with regard to increasing student motivation.
1
A meta-analysis of 139 subsamples from 132 reports found that problem-, project-, and case-based learning produced a small-to-moderate positive effect on student motivation (d = 0.498).
2
Effects were larger for students’ competence and control beliefs, task values, and subject attitudes than for their intrinsic or extrinsic reasons for studying.
3
No significant differences in motivation were found among problem-based, project-based, and case-based learning.
4
Problem-driven learning produced larger motivational effects when implemented within a single course rather than across an entire curriculum, and effects were stronger in healthcare and STEM domains.
5
The motivational effects were heterogeneous, indicating that outcomes varied across studies and implementation contexts.

Students undergoing problem-based, project-based, or case-based learning compared with teacher-centered, lecture-based instruction

The effects of problem-driven learning methods on students’ multifaceted motivation, including beliefs, task values, reasons for engagement, and attitudes toward academic subjects, with variation by instructional method, academic domain, and implementation level

Publication Details
Publication Date
2024-02-28
Journal
Publisher
ISSN
Cited by
590
Access Type
Author Information
Authors
Lidia R. Arends
Lisette Wijnia
Remy M. J. P. Rikers
Sofie M. M. Loyens
Gera Noordzij
Explore further
Open the scid.ai AI chat with a ready-made request: it will find papers on a similar topic and help build a literature review.
Find similar papers in the chat →
Make a presentation
100%