“Protect yourself, sir!”: About the dissertational culture of the scientific community of historians in pre-revolutionary Russia
«Защищайтесь, сударь!»: О диссертационной культуре научного сообщества историков в дореволюционной России
2023-04-21
SCID: 54.1/5k632n2q
Discuss with AI
Russian EmpireRussian historiansdissertation culturedissertation defensehistorical sciences database
Figures from the paper
Abstract (AI)
В рецензии анализируется коллективная монография под редакцией Н.Н. Алеврас и Н.В. Гришиной «Диссертационная культура российского историко-научного сообщества: опыт и практики подготовки и защит диссертаций (XIX – начало XX в.)» (2022). Авторы исследуют нормативно-правовые, институциональные, методологические, коммуникативные и коммеморативные аспекты защиты диссертаций по историческим разрядам наук в дореволюционной России, прослеживают становление практик подготовки и защиты диссертации как форм профессиональной культуры ученых-историков. Заслугой авторов является формирование и детальный анализ базы данных о 280 диссертантах и 409 диссертациях по истории. This book review is devoted to the analysis of the collective monograph ed. by N.N. Alevras and N.V. Grishina “Dissertational culture of the Russian historical scientific community: experience and practice of writing and defending dissertations (XIX – early XX c.)” (2022). The authors examine the regulatory, institutional, methodological, communicative and commemorative aspects of the defense of dissertations in historical sciences in the Russian Empire, study the practices for writing and defending dissertationsas forms of the professional culture of historians. The merit of the authors is the formation and detailed analysis of the database, which includes data on 280 scientists and 409 dissertations in history.
Key Findings
1
It examines regulatory, institutional, methodological, communicative, and commemorative dimensions of defending dissertations in the historical sciences.
2
The authors developed and analyzed a database containing information on 280 dissertation candidates and 409 history dissertations.
3
The reviewed monograph analyzes dissertation culture among historians in pre-revolutionary Russia from the nineteenth to early twentieth century.
4
The study traces the emergence of dissertation preparation and defense practices as components of historians’ professional culture.
Research Object
Dissertation preparation and defense practices in historical sciences in pre-revolutionary Russia
Research Subject
The regulatory, institutional, methodological, communicative, and commemorative aspects and professional-cultural formation of dissertation preparation and defense
Publication Details
Publication Date
2023-04-21
Journal
Publisher
ISSN
Cited by
1
Open access PDF
Access Type
Author Information
Download PDF
Subscribe to digest