Is alcohol a tropical medicine? Scientific understandings of climate, stimulants and bodies in Victorian and Edwardian tropical travel

Является ли алкоголь тропическим лекарством? Научные представления о климате, стимуляторах и человеческом теле в путешествиях по тропикам викторианской и эдвардианской эпох
Edward Armston‐Sheret, Kim Walker
2021-09-24

British explorersalcohol and climateracial differencetropical Africatropical medicine
This paper offers a new perspective on historical understandings of the relationship between alcohol, climate and the body, by studying the way that British explorers of tropical Africa drank alcohol and wrote about drink between c.1850 and c.1910. We demonstrate that alcohol was simultaneously classified as a medicinal, a preventative and a pleasurable drink, shaped by competing medical theories, but that distinctions between these different roles were highly blurred. We also show how many explorers thought certain drinks helped to protect white bodies from the effects of tropical diseases. While popular amongst travellers, these views came under growing scrutiny in the latter part of the nineteenth century, reflecting both changing scientific views about the relationship between alcohol, climate and the body and the development of a much larger European presence in tropical Africa. However, even those who opposed tropical drinking often supported the use of other stimulants and viewed the tropics as uniquely dangerous. As such, the paper challenges the idea that the late nineteenth century marked a paradigm shift in scientific attitudes towards tropical environments, as much previous scholarship has suggested. At the same time, our examinations of explorers' descriptions of drinking by African people demonstrates how ideas about racial difference played an important role within medical understandings of alcohol. Overall, this paper examines the heterogeny of attitudes to alcohol to be found within tropical medicine and documents the continuities in approach shown between the nineteenth and twentieth centuries.
1
Descriptions of African drinking show that racial difference significantly shaped medical understandings of alcohol, revealing continuities between nineteenth- and twentieth-century approaches.
2
Late-nineteenth-century skepticism toward tropical drinking reflected changing medical theories and expanding European presence, but often retained support for other stimulants.
3
Many explorers believed particular alcoholic drinks protected white bodies from tropical diseases and climate-related effects.
4
The persistence of beliefs that tropical environments were uniquely dangerous challenges claims of a sharp late-nineteenth-century paradigm shift in tropical medicine.
5
Victorian and Edwardian British explorers classified alcohol simultaneously as medicinal, preventive, and pleasurable, with boundaries between these roles often blurred.

British explorers' alcohol consumption and writings about drinking in tropical Africa between c.1850 and c.1910

Historical medical understandings and changing attitudes toward alcohol, climate, tropical disease, bodily protection, stimulants, and racial difference

Publication Details
Publication Date
2021-09-24
Journal
Publisher
ISSN
Cited by
3
Access Type
Author Information
Authors
Edward Armston‐Sheret
Kim Walker
Explore further
Open the scid.ai AI chat with a ready-made request: it will find papers on a similar topic and help build a literature review.
Find similar papers in the chat
Make a presentation
100%