Identity Options in Russian Textbooks

Варианты идентичности в учебниках русского языка
Marya Shardakova, Aneta Pavlenko
2004-01-01

Russian language textbookscritical discourse analysisidentity optionsimagined learnersintercultural competence
This article introduces a new analytical approach to the study of identity options offered in foreign and second language textbooks. This approach, grounded in poststructuralist theory and critical discourse analysis, is applied to 2 popular beginning Russian textbooks. Two sets of identity options are examined in the study: imagined learners (targeted implicitly by the texts) and imagined interlocutors (invoked explicitly). It is argued that, while one text, Russian Stage 1, offers a richer variety of identity options for the students, neither book fully reflects the diversity of contemporary Russian society. The biases and oversimplifications identified in the texts represent lost opportunities for cross-cultural reflection; they may also negatively affect the students and deprive them of important means of self-representation and at times even self-defense. The discussion suggests some directions for future research inquiry, as well as for material writing and classroom practice that would promote intercultural competence and critical language awareness. Key words: identity, critical pedagogy, foreign language textbooks, Russian
1
Analysis of two popular beginning Russian textbooks distinguishes between implicitly targeted imagined learners and explicitly invoked imagined interlocutors.
2
Neither textbook adequately represents the diversity of contemporary Russian society, exhibiting biases and oversimplifications.
3
Russian Stage 1 provides a richer variety of identity options for students than the other examined textbook.
4
The article develops a poststructuralist and critical discourse analysis approach for examining identity options in foreign- and second-language textbooks.
5
These representational limitations may hinder cross-cultural reflection, restrict students’ self-representation and self-defense, and undermine intercultural competence and critical language awareness.

identity options represented in two beginning Russian language textbooks (Russian Stage 1 and another popular textbook)

the diversity, biases, and cultural representation of imagined learners and imagined interlocutors addressed by the textbooks

Publication Details
Publication Date
2004-01-01
Journal
Publisher
ISSN
Access Type
Author Information
Authors
Marya Shardakova
Aneta Pavlenko
Explore further
Open the scid.ai AI chat with a ready-made request: it will find papers on a similar topic and help build a literature review.
Find similar papers in the chat
Make a presentation
100%