Phylogenetic and Functional Assessment of Orthologs Inference Projects and Methods
Филогенетическая и функциональная оценка проектов и методов предсказания ортологов
2009-01-15
SCID: 54.1/63shv8us
Discuss with AI
bidirectional best-hitcomparative genomicsfunctional conservationortholog inferencephylogenetic assessment
Figures from the paper
Abstract (AI)
Accurate genome-wide identification of orthologs is a central problem in comparative genomics, a fact reflected by the numerous orthology identification projects developed in recent years. However, only a few reports have compared their accuracy, and indeed, several recent efforts have not yet been systematically evaluated. Furthermore, orthology is typically only assessed in terms of function conservation, despite the phylogeny-based original definition of Fitch. We collected and mapped the results of nine leading orthology projects and methods (COG, KOG, Inparanoid, OrthoMCL, Ensembl Compara, Homologene, RoundUp, EggNOG, and OMA) and two standard methods (bidirectional best-hit and reciprocal smallest distance). We systematically compared their predictions with respect to both phylogeny and function, using six different tests. This required the mapping of millions of sequences, the handling of hundreds of millions of predicted pairs of orthologs, and the computation of tens of thousands of trees. In phylogenetic analysis or in functional analysis where high specificity is required, we find that OMA and Homologene perform best. At lower functional specificity but higher coverage level, OrthoMCL outperforms Ensembl Compara, and to a lesser extent Inparanoid. Lastly, the large coverage of the recent EggNOG can be of interest to build broad functional grouping, but the method is not specific enough for phylogenetic or detailed function analyses. In terms of general methodology, we observe that the more sophisticated tree reconstruction/reconciliation approach of Ensembl Compara was at times outperformed by pairwise comparison approaches, even in phylogenetic tests. Furthermore, we show that standard bidirectional best-hit often outperforms projects with more complex algorithms. First, the present study provides guidance for the broad community of orthology data users as to which database best suits their needs. Second, it introduces new methodology to verify orthology. And third, it sets performance standards for current and future approaches.
Key Findings
1
EggNOG’s broad coverage supports general functional grouping, but its specificity is insufficient for phylogenetic or detailed functional analyses.
2
More complex tree reconstruction and reconciliation in Ensembl Compara can be outperformed by pairwise methods; bidirectional best-hit often surpasses more sophisticated algorithms.
3
OMA and Homologene perform best in phylogenetic analyses and functional analyses requiring high specificity.
4
OrthoMCL provides better performance than Ensembl Compara, and somewhat better than Inparanoid, when functional specificity is lower but coverage is higher.
5
The study systematically compares nine major orthology projects and two standard methods using six tests covering both phylogenetic accuracy and functional conservation.
Research Object
genome-wide ortholog predictions produced by orthology identification projects and methods
Research Subject
the phylogenetic accuracy, functional conservation, specificity, coverage, and comparative performance of orthology inference projects and methods
Publication Details
Publication Date
2009-01-15
Journal
Publisher
ISSN
Cited by
420
Open access PDF
Access Type
Author Information
Download PDF
Subscribe to digest