POLITICAL REPRESENTATION IN COMPARATIVE POLITICS

Политическое представительство в сравнительной политологии
G. Bingham Powell
2004-05-17

comparative politicselectoral systemspolitical representationsubstantive representationvote-seat representation
▪ Abstract Two large research programs have analyzed election-based connections between citizens and policy makers in different democracies. Studies of vote-seat representation in the tradition of Rae (1967) begin with citizens' party votes and have made substantial progress in elucidating the impact of election laws, geographic vote distributions, and the number of parties and their interactions on the proportionality of party representation. Studies of substantive representation in the tradition of Miller & Stokes (1963) begin with citizen issue preferences and link these to the positions of their representatives. Most studies outside the United States, confronting multimember districts and the cohesion of party representatives, have focused on voter-party dyads rather than geographic constituencies, and confirmed the importance of issues linked to a common electoral discourse and the greater structure of legislator issue positions. Recently, a number of explicitly comparative analyses have begun to analyze collective correspondence and confront other limitations of the literature.
1
Cross-national research finds that substantive correspondence is strongest for issues embedded in a shared electoral discourse and reflects the broader structure of legislators’ issue positions.
2
Outside the United States, studies commonly analyze voter-party relationships rather than geographic constituencies because of multimember districts and cohesive party representatives.
3
Recent comparative studies analyze collective correspondence and address limitations that constrained earlier representation research.
4
Research on vote-seat representation has clarified how electoral laws, geographic vote distributions, party-system size, and party interactions shape proportionality.
5
Substantive representation research links citizens’ issue preferences to the policy positions of their representatives.

Election-based connections between citizens and policy makers in different democracies

Vote-seat and substantive representation, including the effects of electoral systems, geographic vote distributions, party-system structure, and correspondence between citizen preferences and representatives’ policy positions

Publication Details
Publication Date
2004-05-17
Journal
Publisher
ISSN
Access Type
Author Information
Authors
G. Bingham Powell
Explore further
Open the scid.ai AI chat with a ready-made request: it will find papers on a similar topic and help build a literature review.
Find similar papers in the chat
Make a presentation
100%