Formation Damage Caused by a Water Blockage Chemical: Prevention Through Operator Supported Test Programs
Повреждение пласта, вызванное химическим составом для устранения водяной блокады: предотвращение с помощью испытательных программ при поддержке оператора
2002-02-01
SCID: 54.1/83wf426w
Discuss with AI
core flood studiesformation damagephosphonate-based scale inhibitorrelative permeabilitywater blockage
Figures from the paper
Abstract (AI)
Abstract Recently, a Saudi Arabian well producing out of a carbonate reservoir was squeezed with a scale control chemical (a phosphonate-based inhibitor). The target zone has a low permeability of nearly 20 mD. The treatment adversely affected oil production, and the damage was attributed to water blockage after the treatment. Several solvents that can remove water blockage were tested, including ethylene glycol monobutylether (EGMBE) and a proprietary chemical designated as E-2. The latter chemical is a patented blend of glycol ethers and has been proven successful in many field applications in the North Sea environment. The chemical is typically applied as a 15 percent by volume mixture in appropriate brines. On this occasion, however, the vendor recommended the chemical be squeezed "neat" into the formation. Concerns as to the effectiveness of the chemical as well as concerns about the cost caused the authors to question the use of the chemical "neat". In house laboratory test programs demonstrated that using the "neat" E-2 chemical would have resulted in severe formation damage from two newly identified mechanisms. The first is precipitation of salts from the formation brine, and the second is the formation of a tight, stabilized emulsion with the native crude oil, possibly stabilized by the precipitated salts. These additional problems would have exacerbated the water blockage problem. The chemical E-2 precipitated salts even when it was co-mingled with the field mixing water. Phase separation of salts was noted at room temperature and reservoir temperature (200-220°F). By comparison, the use of the "neat" EGMBE did not result in precipitation of salts nor emulsion formation. Core flood studies confirmed loss of oil production due to water blockage where relative permeability to oil deceased by nearly 50%. In addition, testing of the neat E-2 chemical showed a loss of approximately 85 percent of the original permeability of reservoir core samples, following treatment. This significant drop in relative permeability to oil was attributed to the formation of a tight emulsion stabilized by precipitated salts. The use of the E-2 chemical at 15 percent concentration was compatible with the formation brine and the field mixing water. It also showed a significant recovery of permeability, however, the efficiency was no better than the EGMBE. Surface tension measurements, and water blockage studies all confirm the effectiveness of the E-2 chemical up to 15 volume percent. E-2 has not been shown to be a cost effective alterative in most applications on Saudi Arabian carbonates. In house evaluation of this chemical prevented extensive formation damage, and resulted in the development of a non-damaging and a cost effective treatment.
Key Findings
1
A phosphonate-based scale-control treatment in a low-permeability carbonate reservoir adversely reduced oil production through water-blockage damage.
2
E-2 precipitated salts when mixed with field water at both room and reservoir temperatures of 200–220°F, whereas neat EGMBE caused neither salt precipitation nor emulsion formation.
3
Laboratory core floods confirmed that water blockage reduced relative permeability to oil by nearly 50%.
4
Neat E-2 reduced reservoir-core permeability by approximately 85%, demonstrating the value of operator-supported laboratory testing before chemical treatment.
5
Using the proprietary E-2 chemical neat would have caused severe additional damage through formation-brine salt precipitation and tight, stabilized crude-oil emulsion formation.
Research Object
A low-permeability carbonate reservoir formation and its reservoir-core samples subjected to scale-control and water-blockage-removal chemicals
Research Subject
Chemical-induced formation damage, including water blockage, salt precipitation, emulsion formation, and associated losses of oil production and permeability
Publication Details
Publication Date
2002-02-01
Journal
Publisher
ISSN
Cited by
26
Access Type
Author Information
Download PDF
Subscribe to digest