What Triggers Public Opposition to Immigration? Anxiety, Group Cues, and Immigration Threat

Что вызывает общественное противодействие иммиграции? Тревожность, групповые сигналы и угроза, связанная с иммиграцией
Nicholas A. Valentino, Ted A. Brader, Elizabeth Suhay
2008-09-29

anxietyelite discoursegroup cuesimmigration threatpolitical action
We examine whether and how elite discourse shapes mass opinion and action on immigration policy. One popular but untested suspicion is that reactions to news about the costs of immigration depend uponwho the immigrants are.We confirm this suspicion in a nationally representative experiment: news about the costs of immigration boosts white opposition far more when Latino immigrants, rather than European immigrants, are featured. We find these group cues influence opinion and political action by triggering emotions—in particular, anxiety—not simply by changing beliefs about the severity of the immigration problem. A second experiment replicates these findings but also confirms their sensitivity to the stereotypic consistency of group cues and their context. While these results echo recent insights about the power of anxiety, they also suggest the public is susceptible to error and manipulation when group cues trigger anxiety independently of the actual threat posed by the group.
1
A second experiment replicates the effects and shows that responses depend on the stereotypic consistency and contextual framing of group cues.
2
Anxiety can be triggered independently of a group’s actual threat, making the public vulnerable to error and elite manipulation.
3
Group cues shape immigration opinions and political action primarily by triggering anxiety, rather than merely changing beliefs about immigration’s severity.
4
News emphasizing immigration’s costs increases white opposition substantially more when it features Latino immigrants than European immigrants.

Public reactions to news about the costs of immigration, featuring Latino versus European immigrants

The effects of immigrant-group cues on opposition to immigration policy and political action through anxiety, beliefs about immigration threat, and contextual or stereotypic consistency

Publication Details
Publication Date
2008-09-29
Journal
Publisher
ISSN
Cited by
1304
Access Type
Author Information
Authors
Nicholas A. Valentino
Ted A. Brader
Elizabeth Suhay
Explore further
Open the scid.ai AI chat with a ready-made request: it will find papers on a similar topic and help build a literature review.
Find similar papers in the chat →
Make a presentation
100%