A new valuation school: Integrating diverse values of nature in resource and land use decisions

Новая школа оценки: интеграция многообразных ценностей природы в принятие решений об использовании ресурсов и земель
Sander Jacobs, Nicolas Dendoncker, Berta Martín‐López, David N. Barton, Erik Gómez‐Baggethun, Fanny Boeraeve, Francesca L. McGrath, Kati Vierikko, Davide Geneletti, Katharina J. Sevecke, Nathalie Pipart, Eeva Primmer, Peter Mederly, Stefan Schmidt, Alexandra Aragão, Himlal Baral, Rosalind H. Bark, Tania Briceño, Delphine Brogna, Pedro Cabral, Rik De Vreese, Camino Liquete, Hannah Mueller, Kelvin S.‐H. Peh, Anna Phelan, Alexander R. Rincón, Shannon Rogers, Francis Turkelboom, Wouter Van Reeth, Boris T. van Zanten, Hilde Karine Wam, Carla-Leanne Washbourne
2016-12-01

diverse values of natureintegrated valuationland use decisionsnatural resource decision-makingtransdisciplinary science
We are increasingly confronted with severe social and economic impacts of environmental degradation all over the world. From a valuation perspective, environmental problems and conflicts originate from trade-offs between values. The urgency and importance to integrate nature's diverse values in decisions and actions stand out more than ever. Valuation, in its broad sense of ‘assigning importance’, is inherently part of most decisions on natural resource and land use. Scholars from different traditions -while moving from heuristic interdisciplinary debate to applied transdisciplinary science- now acknowledge the need for combining multiple disciplines and methods to represent the diverse set of values of nature. This growing group of scientists and practitioners share the ambition to explore how combinations of ecological, socio-cultural and economic valuation tools can support real-life resource and land use decision-making. The current sustainability challenges and the ineffectiveness of single-value approaches to offer relief demonstrate that continuing along a single path is no option. We advocate for the adherence of a plural valuation culture and its establishment as a common practice, by contesting and complementing ineffective and discriminatory single-value approaches. In policy and decision contexts with a willingness to improve sustainability, integrated valuation approaches can be blended in existing processes, whereas in contexts of power asymmetries or environmental conflicts, integrated valuation can promote the inclusion of diverse values through action research and support the struggle for social and environmental justice. The special issue and this editorial synthesis paper bring together lessons from pioneer case studies and research papers, synthesizing main challenges and setting out priorities for the years to come for the field of integrated valuation.
1
A plural valuation culture should become common practice by contesting and complementing single-value approaches.
2
Environmental problems and conflicts arise from trade-offs among diverse values of nature, making valuation central to resource and land-use decisions.
3
Integrated valuation can be embedded in sustainability-oriented policy processes and, amid power asymmetries or conflicts, promote inclusion, action research, and social and environmental justice.
4
Integrating ecological, socio-cultural, and economic valuation methods can better support real-world natural resource and land-use decision-making.
5
Single-value approaches are ineffective for addressing current sustainability challenges and may reinforce discriminatory outcomes.

natural resource and land use decision-making processes

integration of diverse ecological, socio-cultural, and economic values of nature to support sustainable, inclusive, and just decisions

Publication Details
Publication Date
2016-12-01
Journal
Publisher
ISSN
Access Type
Author Information
Authors
Sander Jacobs
Nicolas Dendoncker
Berta Martín‐López
David N. Barton
Erik Gómez‐Baggethun
Fanny Boeraeve
Francesca L. McGrath
Kati Vierikko
Davide Geneletti
Katharina J. Sevecke
Nathalie Pipart
Eeva Primmer
Peter Mederly
Stefan Schmidt
Alexandra Aragão
Himlal Baral
Rosalind H. Bark
Tania Briceño
Delphine Brogna
Pedro Cabral
Rik De Vreese
Camino Liquete
Hannah Mueller
Kelvin S.‐H. Peh
Anna Phelan
Alexander R. Rincón
Shannon Rogers
Francis Turkelboom
Wouter Van Reeth
Boris T. van Zanten
Hilde Karine Wam
Carla-Leanne Washbourne
Explore further
Open the scid.ai AI chat with a ready-made request: it will find papers on a similar topic and help build a literature review.
Find similar papers in the chat →
Make a presentation
100%