Comparison of Direct and Indirect Approaches to PV Power Estimation

Сравнение прямого и косвенного подходов к оценке мощности фотоэлектрических установок
Alisher F. Narynbaev, Vladislav A. Kremer, Alexey Vaskov
2024-02-29

Bichurskaya PV power plantMLP modelPV power estimationPVOD datadirect approachindirect approachnRMSE 3.3%nRMSE 5.3%pvlib model chain
This study compares direct and indirect approaches for estimating the output power of solar photovoltaic plants. The effectiveness of the direct approach is assessed through a case study of the Bichurskaya PV power plant, utilizing a supervised machine learning model, specifically the MLP model. Data from two grid-connected PV power plants, based on PVOD data, is used to evaluate the performance of the indirect approach, which involves sequential mathematical modeling of PV plant components using models from the pvlib library. Results indicate that, with sufficient input data, the direct approach is able to surpass traditional mathematical modelling in PV plant output power estimation. The MLP model achieved an nRMSE metric of 3.3%, while the model chain demonstrated a 5.3% performance on the same dataset.
1
A sequential model chain using pvlib-based component models (indirect approach) produced an nRMSE of 5.3% on the same dataset.
2
An MLP model applied to the Bichurskaya PV plant achieved an nRMSE of 3.3% on the evaluated dataset.
3
Comparison used PVOD data from two grid-connected PV plants to evaluate the indirect (model chain) approach and a case study for the direct (MLP) approach.
4
Direct (supervised ML) approach can outperform traditional mathematical modelling for PV plant output estimation when sufficient input data are available.

Solar photovoltaic (PV) plant output power estimation for grid-connected PV power plants (case: Bichurskaya PV power plant)

Comparison of direct (MLP-based supervised machine learning) versus indirect (sequential pvlib component mathematical modeling) approaches in estimating PV plant output power, evaluated by nRMSE performance

Publication Details
Publication Date
2024-02-29
Journal
Publisher
ISSN
Cited by
2
Access Type
Author Information
Authors
Alisher F. Narynbaev
Vladislav A. Kremer
Alexey Vaskov
Explore further
Open the scid.ai AI chat with a ready-made request: it will find papers on a similar topic and help build a literature review.
Find similar papers in the chat
Make a presentation
100%