A Phenomenological Study of Teachers' Challenges in Moving from Behaviourist to Humanistic Pedagogy in a Pakistani Private School

Феноменологическое исследование трудностей учителей при переходе от бихевиористской к гуманистической педагогике в частной школе Пакистана
Rashida Ali Asghar, Dr. Fayyaz Ahmed Shaheen
2026-05-07

behaviourist pedagogyhumanistic pedagogylearner-centred pedagogyphenomenological studythematic analysis
This phenomenological study explores the lived experiences and struggles of secondary school teachers in Pakistani private schools as they shift from behaviourist to humanistic pedagogy. A qualitative research design is used to collect data through semi-structured interviews with eight purposively selected teachers experiencing the transition to learner-centred pedagogy. Findings from thematic analysis revealed that this global shift in pedagogy is a quite complex process, initially perceived as a challenge by teachers but eventually leading to a significant transformation. Both external and internal factors, like rigid assessment policies, large class size, time limitations, parental involvement, lack of professional training, and shift from authoritative to facilitative, played a major role. Despite these barriers, this research highlights positive outcomes for students and teachers, improving students' engagement and confidence in class while boosting teachers' reflective practice and growth. The study concludes that achieving the required outcomes from a humanistic approach in Pakistani private schools requires systematic support and transformation, including professional training for teachers, improving rigid school policies, and gradually adopting a blended environment where traditional and modern teaching styles work together.
1
Humanistic pedagogy improved students’ classroom engagement and confidence while strengthening teachers’ reflective practice and professional growth.
2
Rigid assessment policies, large classes, limited time, parental involvement, insufficient professional training, and changing teacher authority hindered the transition.
3
Successful implementation in Pakistani private schools requires systematic support, including teacher training, policy reform, and gradual integration of traditional and modern teaching styles.
4
The study used thematic analysis of semi-structured interviews with eight purposively selected secondary school teachers experiencing learner-centred pedagogical change.
5
Transitioning from behaviourist to humanistic pedagogy was initially challenging for teachers but ultimately produced significant professional and instructional transformation.

secondary school teachers in Pakistani private schools transitioning from behaviourist to humanistic, learner-centred pedagogy

teachers' lived challenges, influencing factors, and transformative outcomes during the pedagogical transition

Publication Details
Publication Date
2026-05-07
Journal
Publisher
ISSN
Cited by
1
Access Type
Author Information
Authors
Rashida Ali Asghar
Dr. Fayyaz Ahmed Shaheen
Explore further
Open the scid.ai AI chat with a ready-made request: it will find papers on a similar topic and help build a literature review.
Find similar papers in the chat →
Make a presentation
100%