Evaluating Novelty: The Role of Panels in the Selection of R&D Projects

Оценка новизны: роль комиссий в отборе проектов в области исследований и разработок
Ammon J. Salter, Paola Criscuolo, Linus Dahlander, Thorsten Grohsjean
2016-03-08

R&D project selectionpanel expertise diversitypanel workloadproject noveltyselection panels
Building on a unique, multi-source, and multi-method study of R&D projects in a leading professional services firm, we develop the argument that organizations are more likely to fund projects with intermediate levels of novelty. That is, some project novelty increases the share of requested funds received, but too much novelty is difficult to appreciate and is selected against. While prior research has considered the characteristics of the individuals generating project ideas, we shift the focus to the panel of selectors and explore how they shape the evaluation of novelty. We theorize that a high panel workload reduces panel preference for novelty in selection, whereas a diversity of panel expertise and a shared location between panel and applicant increase preference for novelty. We explore the implications of these findings for theories of innovation search, organizational selection, and managerial practice.
1
Increasing project novelty initially raises the share of requested funding received, but excessive novelty is selected against because panels find it difficult to appreciate.
2
Organizations are most likely to fund R&D projects with intermediate novelty rather than projects exhibiting very low or very high novelty.
3
Panel characteristics shape novelty evaluation: higher workload reduces preference for novelty, while diverse expertise increases it.
4
Shared location between evaluators and applicants increases panel preference for selecting novel projects.
5
The study shifts attention from idea generators to selector panels, informing theories of innovation search, organizational selection, and managerial practice.

R&D project selection by organizational panels in a leading professional services firm

How panel workload, expertise diversity, and shared location shape the evaluation and selection of project novelty, including preference for intermediate novelty

Publication Details
Publication Date
2016-03-08
Journal
Publisher
ISSN
Cited by
253
Access Type
Author Information
Authors
Ammon J. Salter
Paola Criscuolo
Linus Dahlander
Thorsten Grohsjean
Explore further
Open the scid.ai AI chat with a ready-made request: it will find papers on a similar topic and help build a literature review.
Find similar papers in the chat →
Make a presentation
100%