Animal welfare with and without consciousness
Благополучие животных при наличии и отсутствии сознания
2017-01-01
SCID: 54.1/b389pxxs
Discuss with AI
animal consciousnessanimal healthanimal preferencesanimal welfareanimal well-being
Figures from the paper
Abstract (AI)
Abstract Despite recent advances in understanding brain function, consciousness – specifically, how the brain gives rise to conscious experiences – remains ‘the hard problem.’ In humans, there are often multiple routes to the same actions, some of them involving conscious experience, others not. Furthermore, differences in brain circuitry make analogies between humans and other animals more difficult than is generally acknowledged. In this essay, I argue that both the study of consciousness itself and the science of animal welfare benefit from facing up to these difficulties rather than glossing over them. Animal welfare science, although often defining good welfare in term of what animals feel, does not have to be based on assumptions about which species have conscious experiences. Animal welfare (well‐being) can be defined objectively in terms of animal health and what animals want. Such a conscious‐free definition is readily understandable by people with very different views about animals and yet is practical enough to point to what factual scientific information is needed in any given case. While not precluding conscious awareness in other species, it allows animal welfare science to move forward without having solved the hardest biological problem of all.
Key Findings
1
A consciousness-independent welfare definition enables scientific progress without resolving the biological basis of consciousness, while remaining compatible with consciousness in other species.
2
Animal welfare science need not assume which species possess conscious experiences to evaluate welfare effectively.
3
Animal well-being can be defined objectively through health and animals’ preferences, providing a practical and broadly acceptable framework.
4
Consciousness remains an unresolved hard problem, and human behavior can arise through both conscious and nonconscious pathways.
5
Differences in brain circuitry make straightforward analogies between human and animal consciousness scientifically unreliable.
Research Object
animal welfare in nonhuman animals
Research Subject
the objective, consciousness-independent definition and scientific assessment of animal welfare in terms of animal health and preferences
Publication Details
Publication Date
2017-01-01
Journal
Publisher
ISSN
Open access PDF
Access Type
Author Information
Download PDF
Subscribe to digest