Shipwrecks and ancient trade in the Mediterranean
Кораблекрушения и древняя торговля в Средиземноморье
1984-11-01
SCID: 54.1/b8n5gqep
Discuss with AI
ancient Mediterranean tradearchaeological data qualitysampling reliabilityshipwrecks
Figures from the paper
Abstract (AI)
Study of the ancient world, especially of the Roman Empire, has recently featured an increased interest in the economy, and specifically, trade.A number of factors are responsible for this -they include, on the one hand, the influence of Marxism, in considering economic and social (as opposed to political) factors in historical development (cf.Carandini 1968; Hopkins 1983), and, on the other hand, the increased information which has resulted from a greater quantity and quality of archaeological data (cf.Peacock 1977; Lloyd 1977).Increasing subtlety has, however, brought increasing complexity of interpretation and some disappointment.Archaeological techniques now enable us, in some respects anyway, to achieve a 'holistic vision' of the past, but of course full-scale reconstruction of ancient societies is physically and economically impossible.Analytical techniques are increasingly powerful, but their cost in academic time renders rel iabi Ii ty of sampling crucial, and in fact it may be impossible to match available analysis time with usefulness of information obtained.Moreover, the limits of inference from archaeological identifications may be so low as to make such inference banal (e.g.almost any Roman site prod uces some imported material, and is thus in some sense evidence for vigorous commerce).Problems of skew, of imperfectrecovery, and of the unequal distribution of research, probably render the establishment of 'archaeological statistics' impossible.Insights, or at least key samples, may, however, be found in special contexts, three types of which spring to mind:
Key Findings
1
Analytical methods are increasingly powerful but limited by high time costs and sampling reliability, potentially reducing usefulness of obtained information.
2
Archaeological inference is constrained by skewed recovery, unequal research distribution, and low limits of identification, making archaeological statistics likely impossible.
3
Improved archaeological techniques offer a more holistic vision but cannot enable full reconstruction of ancient societies due to physical and economic constraints.
4
Interest in the ancient economy and trade, especially Roman, has grown due to Marxist influence and improved archaeological data quality and quantity.
5
Key insights into ancient trade are most likely to come from special contexts or key samples rather than broad archaeological aggregation.
Research Object
Shipwrecks and associated archaeological assemblages in the Mediterranean
Research Subject
Their value as special contexts for studying ancient trade and the economic exchange patterns of the Roman and broader Mediterranean world, including issues of sampling bias, recovery limits, and interpretive complexity
Publication Details
Publication Date
1984-11-01
Journal
Publisher
ISSN
Open access PDF
Access Type
Author Information
Download PDF
Subscribe to digest