What Do We Mean by Sustainable Finance? Assessing Existing Frameworks and Policy Risks

Что мы понимаем под устойчивым финансированием? Оценка существующих концептуальных рамок и политических рисков
Marco Migliorelli
2021-01-19

Paris AgreementSustainable Development Goalsfinance for sustainabilitygreenwashingsustainable finance
I observe that the sustainable finance landscape as it stands today is featured by an overabundance of heterogeneous concepts, definitions, industry and policy standards. I argue that such heterogeneity may hinder the smooth development of the conceptual thinking underpinning sustainable finance and originates specific risks that may harm the credibility of the nascent market. These risks include green and sustainable washing, the rebranding of financial flows without additionality, the disordered adjustment in the cost of capital spreads between industries. I argue that to reflect the actual industry and policy context as wells as to steer conceptual and applied practice sustainable finance should be today referred to as “finance for sustainability”. To this extent, both its definition and implementing standards should make clear reference to the relevant sustainability dimensions (in particular in line with the Sustainable Development Goals and the Paris Agreement) and to the sectors or activities that positively contribute to these dimensions.
1
Conceptual and regulatory heterogeneity may impede coherent development of sustainable finance and undermine the credibility of its emerging market.
2
Definitions and implementation standards should explicitly reference sustainability dimensions, especially the Sustainable Development Goals and Paris Agreement, and identify contributing sectors or activities.
3
Identified policy risks include greenwashing, sustainable-washing, relabeling financial flows without additionality, and disorderly changes in cross-industry cost-of-capital spreads.
4
The paper advocates replacing “sustainable finance” with “finance for sustainability” to better reflect industry and policy realities and guide practice.
5
The sustainable finance landscape contains an overabundance of heterogeneous concepts, definitions, industry standards, and policy frameworks.

sustainable finance frameworks, concepts, definitions, and industry and policy standards

heterogeneity of sustainable finance frameworks and standards and its implications for conceptual coherence, market credibility, greenwashing, financial-flow additionality, cost-of-capital spreads, and alignment with sustainability dimensions

Publication Details
Publication Date
2021-01-19
Journal
Publisher
ISSN
Cited by
228
Access Type
Author Information
Authors
Marco Migliorelli
Explore further
Open the scid.ai AI chat with a ready-made request: it will find papers on a similar topic and help build a literature review.
Find similar papers in the chat
Make a presentation
100%