Replication concerns in sports and exercise science: a narrative review of selected methodological issues in the field

Проблемы воспроизводимости в спортивной науке и науке о физических упражнениях: нарративный обзор отдельных методологических вопросов в данной области
Daniël Lakens, Jennifer Murphy, Cristian Mesquida, Joe P. Warne
2022-12-01

publication biasquestionable research practicesreplication crisissports and exercise scienceunderpowered studies
Known methodological issues such as publication bias, questionable research practices and studies with underpowered designs are known to decrease the replicability of study findings. The presence of such issues has been widely established across different research fields, especially in psychology. Their presence raised the first concerns that the replicability of study findings could be low and led researchers to conduct large replication projects. These replication projects revealed that a significant portion of original study findings could not be replicated, giving rise to the conceptualization of the replication crisis. Although previous research in the field of sports and exercise science has identified the first warning signs, such as an overwhelming proportion of significant findings, small sample sizes and lack of data availability, their possible consequences for the replicability of our field have been overlooked. We discuss the consequences of the above issues on the replicability of our field and offer potential solutions to improve replicability.
1
Publication bias, questionable research practices, and underpowered study designs are methodological issues that can reduce the replicability of sports and exercise science findings.
2
Sports and exercise science shows warning signs associated with low replicability, including an overwhelming proportion of significant results, small sample sizes, and limited data availability.
3
The potential consequences of these methodological issues for replicability in sports and exercise science have been insufficiently addressed.
4
The review discusses how these issues may contribute to replication problems and outlines potential solutions for improving replicability in the field.

replicability of findings in sports and exercise science

methodological issues affecting replicability, including publication bias, questionable research practices, underpowered designs, small sample sizes, and lack of data availability

Publication Details
Publication Date
2022-12-01
Journal
Publisher
ISSN
Cited by
107
Access Type
Author Information
Authors
Daniël Lakens
Jennifer Murphy
Cristian Mesquida
Joe P. Warne
Explore further
Open the scid.ai AI chat with a ready-made request: it will find papers on a similar topic and help build a literature review.
Find similar papers in the chat →
Make a presentation
100%