Noise and spatial resolution properties of a commercially available deep learning‐based CT reconstruction algorithm

Шумовые характеристики и пространственное разрешение коммерчески доступного алгоритма реконструкции КТ на основе глубокого обучения
Ehsan Samei, Justin Solomon, Daniele Marin, Peijei Lyu
2020-06-07

CT image quality phantomdeep learning-based CT reconstructionnoise power spectrumnoise spatial distributiontask transfer function
Purpose To characterize the noise and spatial resolution properties of a commercially available deep learning‐based computed tomography (CT) reconstruction algorithm. Methods Two phantom experiments were performed. The first used a multisized image quality phantom (Mercury v3.0, Duke University) imaged at five radiation dose levels (CTDIvol: 0.9, 1.2, 3.6, 7.0, and 22.3 mGy) with a fixed tube current technique on a commercial CT scanner (GE Revolution CT). Images were reconstructed with conventional (FBP), iterative (GE ASiR‐V), and deep learning‐based (GE True Fidelity) reconstruction algorithms. Noise power spectrum (NPS), high‐contrast (air–polyethylene interface), and intermediate‐contrast (water–polyethylene interface) task transfer functions (TTF) were measured for each dose level and phantom size and summarized in terms of average noise frequency (fav) and frequency at which the TTF was reduced to 50% (f50%), respectively. The second experiment used a custom phantom with low‐contrast rods and lung texture sections for the assessment of low‐contrast TTF and noise spatial distribution. The phantom was imaged at five dose levels (CTDIvol: 1.0, 2.1, 3.0, 6.0, and 10.0 mGy) with 20 repeated scans at each dose, and images reconstructed with the same reconstruction algorithms. The local noise stationarity was assessed by generating spatial noise maps from the ensemble of repeated images and computing a noise inhomogeneity index, , following AAPM TG233 methods. All measurements were compared among the algorithms. Results Compared to FBP, noise magnitude was reduced on average (± one standard deviation) by 74 ± 6% and 68 ± 4% for ASiR‐V (at “100%” setting) and True Fidelity (at “High” setting), respectively. The noise texture from ASiR‐V had substantially lower noise frequency content with 55 ± 4% lower NPS fav compared to FBP while True Fidelity had only marginally different noise frequency content with 9 ± 5% lower NPS fav compared to FBP. Both ASiR‐V and True Fidelity demonstrated locally nonstationary noise in a lung texture background at all radiation dose levels, with higher noise near high‐contrast edges of vessels and lower noise in uniform regions. At the 1.0 mGy dose level values were 314% and 271% higher in ASiR‐V and True Fidelity compared to FBP, respectively. High‐contrast spatial resolution was similar between all algorithms for all dose levels and phantom sizes (<3% difference in TTF f50%). Compared to FBP, low‐contrast spatial resolution was lower for ASiR‐V and True Fidelity with a reduction of TTF f50% of up to 42% and 36%, respectively. Conclusions The deep learning‐based CT reconstruction demonstrated a strong noise magnitude reduction compared to FBP while maintaining similar noise texture and high‐contrast spatial resolution. However, the algorithm resulted in images with a locally nonstationary noise in lung textured backgrounds and had somewhat degraded low‐contrast spatial resolution similar to what has been observed in currently available iterative reconstruction techniques.
1
ASiR-V substantially altered noise texture, reducing average NPS frequency by 55 ± 4% versus FBP, whereas True Fidelity changed it marginally by 9 ± 5%.
2
Compared with FBP, image noise magnitude decreased by 74 ± 6% with ASiR-V and 68 ± 4% with True Fidelity at the evaluated settings.
3
Noise power spectra, task transfer functions, and repeated-scan noise maps were used to compare conventional, iterative, and deep learning CT reconstructions across multiple radiation doses.
4
The study characterized dose- and phantom-size-dependent noise, task-based spatial resolution, low-contrast resolution, and noise spatial stationarity for FBP, ASiR-V, and True Fidelity.

Commercially available deep learning-based CT reconstruction algorithm (GE True Fidelity)

Noise magnitude, noise texture and spatial distribution, and high-, intermediate-, and low-contrast spatial resolution properties across radiation dose levels and phantom sizes

Publication Details
Publication Date
2020-06-07
Journal
Publisher
ISSN
Cited by
191
Access Type
Author Information
Authors
Ehsan Samei
Justin Solomon
Daniele Marin
Peijei Lyu
Explore further
Open the scid.ai AI chat with a ready-made request: it will find papers on a similar topic and help build a literature review.
Find similar papers in the chat →
Make a presentation
100%