A roadmap for the future of crowd safety research and practice: Introducing the Swiss Cheese Model of Crowd Safety and the imperative of a Vision Zero target
Дорожная карта будущего исследований и практики в области безопасности массовых мероприятий: представление модели безопасности массовых мероприятий «швейцарский сыр» и необходимость достижения цели «Нулевой травматизм»
2023-08-29
SCID: 54.1/c8x894mg
Discuss with AI
Swiss Cheese ModelVision Zerocrowd safetyincident responserisk assessment
Figures from the paper
Abstract (AI)
Crowds can be subject to intrinsic and extrinsic sources of risk, and previous records have shown that, in the absence of adequate safety measures, these sources of risk can jeopardise human lives. To mitigate these risks, we propose that implementation of multiple layers of safety measures for crowds—what we label The Swiss Cheese Model of Crowd Safety—should become the norm for crowd safety practice. Such system incorporates a multitude of safety protection layers including regulations and policymaking, planning and risk assessment, operational control, community preparedness, and incident response. The underlying premise of such model is that when one (or multiple) layer(s) of safety protection fail(s), the other layer(s) can still prevent an accident. In practice, such model requires a more effective implementation of technology, which can enable provision of real-time data, improved communication and coordination, and efficient incident response. Moreover, implementation of this model necessitates more attention to the overlooked role of public education, awareness raising, and promoting crowd safety culture at broad community levels, as one of last lines of defence against catastrophic outcomes for crowds. Widespread safety culture and awareness has the potential to empower individuals with the knowledge and skills that can prevent such outcomes or mitigate their impacts, when all other (exogenous) layers of protection (such as planning and operational control) fail. This requires safety campaigns and development of widespread educational programs. We conclude that, there is no panacea solution to the crowd safety problem, but a holistic multi-layered safety system that utilises active participation of all potential stakeholders can significantly reduce the likelihood of disastrous accidents. At a global level, we need to target a Vision Zero of Crowd Safety, i.e., set a global initiative of bringing deaths and severe injuries in crowded spaces to zero by a set year.
Key Findings
1
Effective technology use can provide real-time data, improve communication and coordination, and support more efficient incident response in crowd safety management.
2
Public education, awareness, and community-wide safety culture are essential defensive layers that can empower individuals to prevent or mitigate catastrophic crowd outcomes.
3
The authors argue that no single solution eliminates crowd-safety risks; a holistic, stakeholder-inclusive system should pursue a global Vision Zero target for deaths and severe injuries in crowded spaces.
4
The model integrates regulation and policymaking, planning and risk assessment, operational control, community preparedness, and incident response.
5
The paper proposes the Swiss Cheese Model of Crowd Safety, requiring multiple independent protection layers to prevent disasters when individual safeguards fail.
Research Object
crowd safety practice and safety systems for crowds in crowded spaces
Research Subject
the effectiveness and implementation of holistic, multi-layered crowd-safety protection measures aimed at preventing deaths and severe injuries
Publication Details
Publication Date
2023-08-29
Journal
Publisher
ISSN
Cited by
114
Open access PDF
Access Type
Author Information
Download PDF
Subscribe to digest