Literature Review on Maturity Models for Digital Supply Chains
Обзор литературы по моделям зрелости цифровых цепочек поставок
2021-03-26
SCID: 54.1/cz8c7f7k
Discuss with AI
Industry 4.0digital supply chainsmaturity modelsstructured literature reviewsupply chain digitalization
Figures from the paper
Abstract (AI)
Goal. Today, digital technologies have significant effects on supply chains as companies explore and exploit their opportunities. Digital supply chains promise advantages over traditional ones. A maturity model is a helpful tool to assess the current state of digitalization in supply chains and to guide companies towards implementation. The main goal of this paper is to investigate existing maturity models for digital supply chains and propose possibilities for future research. Design/Methodology/Approach. A structured literature review is conducted to identify relevant maturity models. Those are analyzed regarding their type and emphasis on a specific supply chain function or certain digitalization dimension. Results. Twenty-eight maturity models are identified. Each of them focuses on a particular supply chain function or a specific digital technology. A focus on manufacturing (Industry 4.0) and, consequently, a lack of research regarding other aspects of the supply chain digitalization becomes evident. Moreover, most papers lack coverage of all digitalization dimensions. Besides, more rigorous research regarding the quality of the maturity models, their evaluation, and application is needed. Limitations of the investigation. The conducted review is limited to two databases (Scopus and Web of Science). Two researchers conducted the analysis, which might lead to some bias. Furthermore, the analysis could be broadened and performed more in-depth to derive further insights. Practical implications. Practitioners might use the presented overview of existing maturity models to identify a well-developed one that fits their desired application scenario. Originality/value. This paper provides suggestions for future research and highlights interesting and relevant topics to investigate.
Key Findings
1
A structured literature review identified 28 maturity models for assessing and guiding digital supply chain development.
2
Each identified model emphasizes a particular supply chain function or specific digital technology rather than digitalization holistically.
3
Existing research is heavily focused on manufacturing and Industry 4.0, revealing limited attention to other supply chain digitalization aspects.
4
Further rigorous research is needed to assess maturity-model quality, evaluation, and practical application; the review itself is limited to Scopus and Web of Science and may contain researcher bias.
5
Most maturity models do not cover all dimensions of digitalization.
Research Object
digital supply chains and their maturity models
Research Subject
the types, functional or technological focus, digitalization-dimension coverage, quality, evaluation, and application of maturity models for assessing and guiding digital supply-chain digitalization
Publication Details
Publication Date
2021-03-26
Journal
Publisher
ISSN
Cited by
51
Open access PDF
Access Type
Author Information
Download PDF
Subscribe to digest
References available in scid.ai2
Cited by4
Advancing sustainability in the digital age: defining and measuring maturity models for supply chains2025
An Evolutionary Game Approach to Multi-Technology Synergy in Logistics Information Sharing for Smart Supply Chains2025
Measuring digital sustainable maturity in supply chains: a maturity grid proposal2025
Supply Chain & Digital Twins - Mature Enough?2025