Validation of Parental Reports in Assessing Idiopathic Toe Walking Using Quantitative In-Shoe Device Measurements

Валидация родительских сообщений при оценке идиопатической ходьбы на носках с использованием количественных измерений внутрикроссовочных устройств
Bruce A. MacWilliams, Jon Robert Davids, Jeremy Bauer, Susan E. Sienko, Logan D. Morrison, Mark L. McMulkin, Paige Lemhouse
2025-03-12

foot strike patternsidiopathic toe walkingin-shoe device measurementsparental reportsweighted Kappa statistics
BACKGROUND: Toe walking is prevalent among children, affecting 5% to 24% of the pediatric population. Clinicians rely on parental reports of frequency of toe walking to guide clinical decision making and outcomes assessment. However, recall accuracy and differing environments challenge the reliability of parental reports. This study aims to validate parental reports against quantitative in-shoe device measurements (NURVV/RUN). METHODS: Twenty children with persistent idiopathic toe walking (ITWp) (mean age: 9.6y; 13 males, 7 females) from 8 pediatric orthopaedic specialty care sites participated in this multicenter study. Parents assessed toe walking frequency using a 6-point scale, while children wore NURVV/RUN insoles for 8 hours/day over 7 days. Insole sensors recorded foot strike patterns (rearfoot, midfoot, and forefoot), which were classified using the same severity scale. Agreement between parental reports and NURVV data was assessed using weighted Kappa statistics ( P <0.05). RESULTS: Before intervention, children with ITWp exhibited daily walking patterns: 61.7% forefoot, 15.3% midfoot, and 22.8% hindfoot contact. Agreement analysis showed substantial agreement (k=0.688, P <0.001) for combined forefoot and midfoot contacts and fair agreement (k=0.381, P <0.005) for isolated forefoot contact. CONCLUSION: Parental reports of toe walking prevalence in their children are relatively accurate, supporting their use in clinical management. However, quantitative in-shoe devices provide a more objective and quantitative understanding of ITWp frequency and have the potential to guide clinical decision-making and outcomes assessment children with ITWp. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Level II-diagnostic study. See instructions to authors for a complete description of levels of evidence.
1
Agreement was fair for isolated forefoot contact between parental reports and in-shoe measurements (weighted κ=0.381, P<0.005).
2
Before intervention, children demonstrated 61.7% forefoot, 15.3% midfoot, and 22.8% hindfoot daily walking contact patterns.
3
Parental reports showed substantial agreement with combined forefoot and midfoot measurements (weighted κ=0.688, P<0.001).
4
Parental reports were relatively accurate for clinical management, while in-shoe devices offered more objective quantitative assessment for decision-making and outcomes evaluation.
5
The study validated parental reports of idiopathic toe-walking frequency against quantitative NURVV/RUN in-shoe measurements in 20 children.

children with persistent idiopathic toe walking (ITWp)

the accuracy and agreement of parental reports of toe-walking frequency with quantitative in-shoe foot-strike measurements

Publication Details
Publication Date
2025-03-12
Journal
Publisher
ISSN
Cited by
2
Access Type
Author Information
Authors
Bruce A. MacWilliams
Jon Robert Davids
Jeremy Bauer
Susan E. Sienko
Logan D. Morrison
Mark L. McMulkin
Paige Lemhouse
Explore further
Open the scid.ai AI chat with a ready-made request: it will find papers on a similar topic and help build a literature review.
Find similar papers in the chat →
Make a presentation
100%