AI literacy in K-12: a systematic literature review

Грамотность в области искусственного интеллекта в системе образования K–12: систематический обзор литературы
Lorena Casal Otero, Alejandro Catalá, Carmen Fernández-Morante, M. Taboada, Beatriz Cebreiro López, Senén Barro
2023-04-19

AI educationAI literacyK-12 educationcompetency frameworksystematic literature review
Abstract The successful irruption of AI-based technology in our daily lives has led to a growing educational, social, and political interest in training citizens in AI. Education systems now need to train students at the K-12 level to live in a society where they must interact with AI. Thus, AI literacy is a pedagogical and cognitive challenge at the K-12 level. This study aimed to understand how AI is being integrated into K-12 education worldwide. We conducted a search process following the systematic literature review method using Scopus. 179 documents were reviewed, and two broad groups of AI literacy approaches were identified, namely learning experience and theoretical perspective. The first group covered experiences in learning technical, conceptual and applied skills in a particular domain of interest. The second group revealed that significant efforts are being made to design models that frame AI literacy proposals. There were hardly any experiences that assessed whether students understood AI concepts after the learning experience. Little attention has been paid to the undesirable consequences of an indiscriminate and insufficiently thought-out application of AI. A competency framework is required to guide the didactic proposals designed by educational institutions and define a curriculum reflecting the sequence and academic continuity, which should be modular, personalized and adjusted to the conditions of the schools. Finally, AI literacy can be leveraged to enhance the learning of disciplinary core subjects by integrating AI into the teaching process of those subjects, provided the curriculum is co-designed with teachers.
1
A systematic review of 179 Scopus-indexed documents identified two dominant K-12 AI-literacy approaches: learning experiences and theoretical perspectives.
2
Few reviewed studies assessed whether students actually understood AI concepts after instruction, indicating a major evaluation gap.
3
Integrating AI into disciplinary teaching may strengthen core-subject learning when curricula are thoughtfully co-designed with teachers.
4
Learning experiences primarily develop technical, conceptual, and applied AI skills within specific domains, while theoretical studies focus on designing AI-literacy models.
5
Research has paid insufficient attention to the undesirable consequences of indiscriminate or poorly planned AI implementation in education.
6
The review calls for a modular, personalized competency framework and curriculum with academic continuity, co-designed with teachers and adaptable to school conditions.

AI literacy in K-12 education

Approaches, curricular frameworks, learning experiences, and assessment of students’ AI knowledge and skills, including the educational consequences of AI integration

Publication Details
Publication Date
2023-04-19
Journal
Publisher
ISSN
Cited by
1111
Access Type
Author Information
Authors
Lorena Casal Otero
Alejandro Catalá
Carmen Fernández-Morante
M. Taboada
Beatriz Cebreiro López
Senén Barro
Explore further
Open the scid.ai AI chat with a ready-made request: it will find papers on a similar topic and help build a literature review.
Find similar papers in the chat →
Make a presentation
100%