A tri‐citation analysis exploring the citation image of Kurt Lewin
Анализ тройного цитирования, исследующий цитатный образ Курта Левина
2002-11-01
SCID: 54.1/e3trumn3
Discuss with AI
Kurt Lewincocitation analysismultidimensional scalingsocial network analysistri-citation analysis
Figures from the paper
Abstract (AI)
Abstract This paper presents the initial phase of a comparison of cocitation and social network analysis methods for the study of scholarly communication. The subject is a case study of the intellectual contributions of the social psychologist, Kurt Lewin. Lewin's “citation image” is examined with an analysis of intellectual “fellow travelers” as viewed by writers who cite both Lewin and other authors. In this paper I report the findings of an author tri‐citation analysis that explores the relationships among authors linked to Lewin by citations in the three ISI databases. Lists of the sixty authors most highly cocited with Lewin in two time periods (1972–1986 and 1987–2001) were derived and then explored with two multivariate techniques: cluster analysis and multidimensional scaling. Findings indicate the continuing diffusion of Lewin's ideas. Group Dynamics and Social Psychology clusters show a shift in members from the early period to the late. The later map shows the growing dominance of organizational development and business management. Although psychology remains a prominent arena for Lewin's ideas there is increasing divergence between the disciplines of psychology and organizational development.
Key Findings
1
Lewin’s ideas continued to diffuse, while the membership of Group Dynamics and Social Psychology author clusters changed between the two periods.
2
Psychology remains prominent, but the later period reveals increasing disciplinary divergence between psychology and organizational development.
3
The later citation map shows increasing dominance of organizational development and business management in the scholarly use of Lewin’s work.
4
The study compares author cocitation and social network analysis for examining scholarly communication through a case study of Kurt Lewin.
5
Tri-citation analysis identified the sixty authors most frequently cocited with Lewin during 1972–1986 and 1987–2001 using three ISI databases.
Research Object
Kurt Lewin’s citation image and the authors linked to him through citations in the ISI databases
Research Subject
The temporal and disciplinary structure of Lewin’s intellectual influence, including co-citation relationships, shifts in author clusters, and divergence between psychology and organizational development
Publication Details
Publication Date
2002-11-01
Journal
Publisher
ISSN
Access Type
Author Information
Download PDF
Subscribe to digest