Balancing Cultural Heritage Conservation: Visual Integrity Assessment to Support Change Management in the Buffer Zone of Chiang Mai Historic City Using GIS and Computer-Generated 3D Modeling
Сбалансированное сохранение культурного наследия: оценка визуальной целостности для поддержки управления изменениями в буферной зоне исторического города Чиангмай с использованием ГИС и компьютерного трехмерного моделирования
2022-04-29
SCID: 54.1/ey9hpuks
Discuss with AI
3D city modelingGIS visibility analysisMountain skyline protectionViewshed analysisVisual integrity assessment
Figures from the paper
Abstract (AI)
The cultural landscape of Chiang Mai city, which is characterized by the interlinkage between mountain and historical settlement, has faced the adverse impacts of visual intrusion in its buffer zone from urbanization. However, there are challenges to creating a quantitative visual evaluation for decision making in response to rapid urban change. This study evaluated the impact of building height on the city skyline and utilized existing cultural heritage locations on the mountain to define a protected visual zone while conducting a 3D-GIS-based visibility analysis to identify obstruction in three scenarios: the actual condition scenario (ACS) considering current conditions, the land use scenario (LUS) considering the land use ordinance, and the proposed scenario (PPS) considering mountain skyline protection, using computer-generated 3D city modeling. The comparative results from the analysis of viewshed, line of sight, and development area calculations revealed that the number of obstructed locations in the LUS decreased by 48.46%, and in the PPS, they decreased by 77.99%, while the development area increased by similar amounts, demonstrating that the city can grow and develop despite stricter height controls. In addition, based on a visual assessment, this study established a buffer distance and intensity to protect the integrity of the heritage while allowing the city to develop.
Key Findings
1
Compared with actual conditions, the land-use scenario reduced obstructed locations by 48.46%, while the proposed skyline-protection scenario reduced them by 77.99%.
2
Existing mountain cultural-heritage locations were used to define a protected visual zone and evaluate obstruction under three development scenarios.
3
Stricter height controls increased protected development areas by similar amounts, indicating that urban growth can continue alongside mountain skyline conservation.
4
The study develops a quantitative 3D-GIS visibility framework for assessing building-height impacts on Chiang Mai’s historic city skyline.
5
The study establishes buffer distance and development-intensity guidance to preserve heritage visual integrity while supporting change management.
Research Object
Chiang Mai Historic City’s cultural landscape and its urban-development buffer zone
Research Subject
The effects of building height and urban-development scenarios on skyline visibility, visual obstructions, and cultural-heritage visual integrity
Publication Details
Publication Date
2022-04-29
Journal
Publisher
ISSN
Cited by
54
Open access PDF
Access Type
Author Information
Download PDF
Subscribe to digest
Cited by6
Assessment of urbanization impact on cultural heritage based on a risk-based cumulative impact assessment method2023
Bibliometric analysis of GIS applications in heritage studies based on Web of Science from 1994 to 20232024
Using natural language processing to identify and evaluate heritage value for buffer zone delineation in Hengdaohezi Town2025
A value-based priority matrix for assessing the attributes of heritage buffer zones: a case of centrally protected monuments in Delhi2026
Advancing Buffer Zone Delineation for Urban Cultural Heritage: A Risk-Based Framework2026
Bridging World Heritage and Local Heritage: Incorporating the Buffer Zone Concept into Chinese Architectural Heritage Protection2025