Valuation of Grade I Built Heritage Assets as Public Real Estate: Legal Provisions, Institutional Practices, and Challenges
Оценка объектов застроенного наследия I категории как объектов государственной недвижимости: правовые положения, институциональная практика и проблемы
2026-01-01
SCID: 54.1/frub4bcp
Discuss with AI
Depreciated Replacement CostGrade I built heritage assetsMPSAS 17fair value accountingpublic sector valuation
Figures from the paper
Abstract (AI)
The transition to accrual-based accounting (MPSAS 17) in the Malaysian public sector has necessitated the financial recognition of heritage assets, theoretically requiring them to be valued at fair value. While recent literature has extensively reviewed theoretical valuation approaches for government-owned assets, there remains a critical paucity of empirical evidence regarding how these mandates are operationalized by practitioners on the ground. This study bridges that gap by investigating the perception and actual practices of government valuers responsible for Grade I heritage properties assets defined by their inalienability and non-market nature. Utilizing a qualitative research design with semi-structured interviews of senior valuation officers, heritage managers and academician across Malaysia, the study uncovers a significant implementation gap. Findings reveal that despite the availability of advanced economic valuation models in academic literature, practitioners are institutionally constrained to the Depreciated Replacement Cost (DRC) method due to severe data scarcity and the absence of specific valuation standards. Furthermore, the study identifies a specialization gap, where high-level valuation expertise is siloed, and a pervasive liability mindset, where heritage significance is viewed as a financial burden rather than an asset enhancer. These findings challenge the efficacy of current one-size-fits-all accounting standards for public heritage and propose a specialized, data-driven valuation framework.
Key Findings
1
A substantial implementation gap exists between advanced academic economic valuation models and valuation practices used by government practitioners.
2
Current one-size-fits-all public accounting standards appear inadequate, motivating a specialized, data-driven valuation framework for heritage assets.
3
Malaysia’s accrual-based MPSAS 17 accounting transition requires financial recognition and fair-value valuation of public heritage assets.
4
Practitioners valuing Grade I heritage properties primarily use Depreciated Replacement Cost because of severe data scarcity and absent specific valuation standards.
5
Valuation expertise is siloed, while a pervasive liability mindset frames heritage significance as a financial burden rather than an asset enhancer.
Research Object
Grade I built heritage assets in Malaysia, particularly government-owned, inalienable, non-market heritage properties
Research Subject
The legal provisions, institutional valuation practices, implementation gap, and constraints affecting the fair-value recognition of Grade I built heritage assets
Publication Details
Publication Date
2026-01-01
Journal
Publisher
ISSN
Cited by
0
Open access PDF
Access Type
Author Information
Download PDF
Subscribe to digest