Well-being at the cost of welfare: Learned helplessness and responsibility in positive psychology and American policy

Благополучие ценой социального обеспечения: выученная беспомощность и ответственность в позитивной психологии и американской политике
Ian James Davidson
2025-06-06

American welfare policylearned helplessnesspersonal responsibilitypositive psychologyself-governance
In this article I trace the connected histories of well-being and welfare within contemporary American social science and policy. Focusing on the postwar concept of learned helplessness and its associated notions like hopelessness, industriousness, and laziness, I trace a genealogy that is part of the story of the rise of positive psychology, as well as the disciplinary and cultural shift toward self-control, self-monitoring, and other aspects of a moral self-governance founded on values of responsibility and persistence in pursuing personal well-being. Springing from animal research on rats, dogs, and pigeons, then swiftly toward human subjects such as sufferers of depression, students, and welfare recipients, the trajectory from helplessness and hopelessness toward responsibility and persistence followed and possibly influenced both attitudes toward welfarism and changes in American welfare policies. From Curt Richter’s work on hopeless rats to Martin Seligman and colleagues’ decades-spanning work that culminated in positive psychology (part of the wider happiness studies and science of well-being movements), psychological research is framed within the wider history of American welfare. Coinciding with a growing disciplinary inclination toward individual self-improvement that valued personal responsibility and persistence as key virtues, welfare was continually reformed and dismantled under the same principles.
1
Psychological emphasis on self-control, self-monitoring, and personal responsibility coincided with changing attitudes toward welfare and reforms that dismantled American welfare programs.
2
Research on learned helplessness evolved from animal studies to investigations of depression, students, and welfare recipients, linking psychological concepts to social policy.
3
The article traces intertwined histories of well-being and welfare in contemporary American social science and policy.
4
The history from Curt Richter’s hopeless rats to Martin Seligman’s positive psychology is situated within broader American happiness and well-being movements.
5
The trajectory from helplessness and hopelessness toward responsibility and persistence contributed to the rise of positive psychology and moral self-governance.

The postwar concept of learned helplessness and its associated psychological and policy trajectory among animal and human subjects in American social science and welfare policy

The genealogy and policy implications of shifting from helplessness and hopelessness toward self-control, personal responsibility, persistence, and well-being

Publication Details
Publication Date
2025-06-06
Journal
Publisher
ISSN
Cited by
0
Access Type
Author Information
Authors
Ian James Davidson
Explore further
Open the scid.ai AI chat with a ready-made request: it will find papers on a similar topic and help build a literature review.
Find similar papers in the chat →
Make a presentation
100%