Plato on why mathematics is good for the soul

Платон о том, почему математика полезна для души
Myles Burnyeat, Carol Atack, Malcolm Schofield, David Sedley
2022-03-24

Plato's philosophyRepublic Book VIIharmonicsmathematical sciencesphilosophy of mathematics
Why does Plato in the Republic attach such importance to mathematics? Not for its practical utility, nor for the transferable skills acquired by the mathematician, nor because of the rigour of the formal procedures of mathematical proof. It is rather that the five mathematical sciences described and explained in Book VII convert the soul from merely human perspective, and tell us how things are objectively speaking. Their content is what counts. They convey knowledge or understanding of the context-invariant truth of unqualified reality. In contrast with modern conceptions of mathematics and its relation to reality, these sciences are conceived as themselves sciences of value. Above all, they enlarge ethical understanding. Crucial here is harmonics, which incorporates principles first studied through the first four sciences that Plato specifies. Mathematical proportion is what underpins the musical structures – the concords – that form the subject matter of harmonics. Such mathematical structures, when internalised by the philosopher, function as abstract schemata for applying their knowledge of the Good in the social world. Plato values them so highly because they create and sustain unity: unity is for him the highest value.
1
Harmonics integrates principles from the preceding mathematical sciences through mathematical proportions underlying musical concords.
2
Mathematics is highly valued because it creates and sustains unity, which Plato regards as the highest value.
3
Plato values mathematics in the Republic primarily because its content converts the soul from a merely human perspective toward objective, context-invariant reality.
4
The five mathematical sciences in Book VII are presented as sciences of value that deepen ethical understanding, rather than as practically useful or merely rigorous disciplines.
5
When internalized by philosophers, mathematical structures function as abstract schemata for applying knowledge of the Good within social life.

Plato's five mathematical sciences in the Republic, especially harmonics and its mathematical proportions

Their role in transforming the soul and enlarging ethical understanding by conveying context-invariant truth and sustaining unity

Publication Details
Publication Date
2022-03-24
Journal
Publisher
ISSN
Cited by
197
Access Type
Author Information
Authors
Myles Burnyeat
Carol Atack
Malcolm Schofield
David Sedley
Explore further
Open the scid.ai AI chat with a ready-made request: it will find papers on a similar topic and help build a literature review.
Find similar papers in the chat
Make a presentation
100%