The Psycho-Biology of Language. Pp. ix + 336 and 7 plates. By George K. Zipf. Boston: Houghton Mifflin Co., 1935.

Психобиология языка. IX + 336 страниц и 7 таблиц. Джордж К. Ципф. Бостон: Houghton Mifflin Co., 1935.
Martin Joos
1936-09-01

Zipf's principlelanguage structurelinguistic phenomenaphonetic changerelative frequency
This is the third publication by Zipf on the theory and application of his principle of relative frequency in the structure and development of language.His first treatise on the subjectl applied the theory to accent and phonology, and laid the foundation which he still uses with inconsiderable modifications.It was reviewed, in a generally sympathetic spirit but with regretful refusal to agree that the problems attacked had been solved, by Elise Richter2 and by Eduard Hermann.3The second book was shorter.4In it Zipf presented his study of the vocabulary of four Plautine plays, and a phonetic, syllabic, and vocabulary study of 20,000 syllables of connected text in the colloquial Chinese of Peiping; there were hints of a contemplated extension into the field of morphology.It was reviewed by Eduard Prokosch5 with a severity that bespoke a painful disappointment of his hopes for the possibilities of the new line of inquiry.In the present volume Zipf embraces the whole range of linguistic study and phenomena, from phonemes to 'the stream of speech and its relation to the totality of behavior'.Apparently nothing remains untouched within that range, and the treatment almost uniformly evidences a belief that the author has attained valid formulations.Further, the book is subtitled 'An Introduction to 1 Relative Frequency as a Determinant of Phonetic Change, Harvard Stud.Class.Phil.40.1-95 (1929). 2 ASNS 157.291-6 (1930).3 PhW 51.598-603 (1931).Other reviews: Kent, LANG.6.86-8, 'not convinced ...despite the statistics'; Meillet, BSL 31.3.17 (1931) (not available, but Meriggi, IdgJb 16, reports 'ablehnend'); Meriggi, IF 50.246-7 (1932), 'calls attention to neglected factor' but 'exaggerated, almost mechanical utilization' and 'paper phonetics'; Sutterlin, LGRPh 52.241-3 (1931), appreciative; Twaddell, Monatshefte f. deut.Unterricht 21. 230-7 (1929), appreciative and constructively critical.4 Selected Studies of the Principle of Relative Frequency in Language (Harvard Univ.Press 1932) viii + 51 and plates 62. 5 LANG.9.89-92.Other reviews: Cohen, BSL 33.3.10 f (1932) (not available); Malone, MLN 48.394 f. (1933) 'deserves credit for taking the first steps' but 'does not seem to realize that his task has just begun.'
1
Earlier applications to Plautine vocabulary and 20,000 syllables of colloquial Peiping Chinese provided empirical foundations for the broader theory, but previous reviewers questioned whether the problems were actually solved.
2
The book presents relative frequency as a general determinant of linguistic structure and development, including phonetic change and anticipated morphological applications.
3
The reviewer notes that Zipf treats nearly all linguistic phenomena as governed by valid formulations, reflecting an expansive and largely confident theoretical program.
4
The volume examines language from phonemes through the speech stream and its relationship to overall human behavior.
5
Zipf’s third publication extends his principle of relative frequency from phonology and vocabulary to the full range of linguistic phenomena.

language structure and development, spanning phonemes, speech, and their relation to behavior

the role of relative frequency as a determinant of linguistic phenomena and change

Publication Details
Publication Date
1936-09-01
Journal
Publisher
ISSN
Access Type
Author Information
Authors
Martin Joos
Explore further
Open the scid.ai AI chat with a ready-made request: it will find papers on a similar topic and help build a literature review.
Find similar papers in the chat
Make a presentation
100%