Pure Theory of Lawlegal norm validitylegal positivismnormativity (ought vs is)positive law
Figures from the paper
Abstract (AI)
The Pure Theory of Law is a theory of positive law, not of a definite legal order, but of the law in general. It is a general theory of law. As such it is the most consistent version of that school of jurisprudence which is called legal positivism because it considers as “law” only positive law and refuses to recognize as law any other normative social order even if, in the usage of language, it is called “law”, as e.g. so-called “natural law”. Law is—according to the Pure Theory of Law—by its very nature a definite type of norm . As a “norm” the law is the specific meaning of an act of will directed at a definite human behavior. This meaning is: that men ought to behave in a certain way. Hence an essential presupposition of the Pure Theory of Law as a positivistic theory is the recognition of the fundamental difference between the “ought” and the “is”, between norms and assertions. Assertions describe a certain object; they are true or false; norms are not de scribing, but pres cribing; they are neither true nor false; they are valid or non-valid. Hence it is necessary to distinguish as clearly as possible between legal norms established by the legal authority, and assertions of the science of law about legal norms , the sentences by which this science describes its object.
Key Findings
1
A fundamental presupposition is the distinction between 'ought' (norms) and 'is' (assertions): norms prescribe and are valid or non-valid, not true or false.
2
The Pure Theory of Law is a general, positivist theory of positive law applicable to law in general rather than a specific legal order.
3
The Pure Theory rejects recognition of other normative orders (e.g., 'natural law') as law, accepting only positive (officially established) law as genuine law.
4
The theory defines law as a specific type of norm: the meaning of an act of will directing human behavior that expresses that people ought to behave in a certain way.
5
The theory requires a clear separation between legal norms established by legal authority and descriptive assertions of the science of law about those norms.
Research Object
The law in general as a system of legal norms (positive law)
Research Subject
The nature and normative status of law: distinguishing legal norms (prescriptive 'ought') from assertions (descriptive 'is'), and the Pure Theory of Law's account of validity, normativity, and legal positivism
Publication Details
Publication Date
1966-01-01
Journal
Publisher
ISSN
Access Type
Author Information
Download PDF
Subscribe to digest