The “torpillage” neurologists of World War I

Неврологи «торпилляжа» в годы Первой мировой войны
Laurent Tatu, Julien Bogousslavsky, Thierry Moulin, Jean-Luc Chopard
2010-07-19

camptocormiaposttraumatic stress disorderpsychoelectric treatmenttorpillagewar neuroses
The French neurologists and psychiatrists who were mobilized during the Great War were confronted with numerous soldiers with war neuroses, often with novel clinical manifestations such as camptocormia. They addressed hysteria and pithiatism according to concepts that had been formed before the war, and many doctors considered these soldiers to be malingerers. As a result, the use of aggressive therapies to enable their prompt return to the battlefront was advocated. In 1915-1916, Clovis Vincent (1879-1947) developed a method called torpillage, a "persuasive" form of psychotherapy using faradic and galvanic electric currents, to treat soldiers with "intractable" neuroses. However, since the treatment was painful, soldiers began to refuse it and, following a publicized trial, the method was discontinued. Given the influx of soldiers with seemingly incurable neuroses, Gustave Roussy (1874-1948) made an attempt in 1917 to develop a new method of psychoelectric treatment. In January 1918, he too came up against soldiers refusing electric treatment. Following a new trial and an unfavorable press campaign, the psycho-faradic method gradually died out. These extreme medical practices developed to treat psychological trauma during the First World War subsequently led to the delineation of posttraumatic stress disorder in more recent wars.
1
Clovis Vincent developed torpillage in 1915–1916, a painful, electrically mediated “persuasive” psychotherapy for soldiers with supposedly intractable neuroses.
2
French military neurologists treated World War I war neuroses, including novel manifestations such as camptocormia, through prewar concepts of hysteria and pithiatism.
3
Many physicians interpreted affected soldiers as malingerers, prompting advocacy of aggressive treatments designed to return them rapidly to the front.
4
Soldiers’ refusal of torpillage, followed by a publicized trial, led to its discontinuation; Gustave Roussy’s later psycho-faradic method similarly declined after refusals, a trial, and adverse press.
5
These extreme wartime treatments for psychological trauma contributed historically to the later delineation of posttraumatic stress disorder.

French neurologists’ and psychiatrists’ wartime treatment practices for soldiers with war neuroses during World War I

The development, use, refusal, and discontinuation of painful electrical psychotherapy methods—torpillage and psycho-faradic treatment—for “intractable” war neuroses

Publication Details
Publication Date
2010-07-19
Journal
Publisher
ISSN
Access Type
Author Information
Authors
Laurent Tatu
Julien Bogousslavsky
Thierry Moulin
Jean-Luc Chopard
Explore further
Open the scid.ai AI chat with a ready-made request: it will find papers on a similar topic and help build a literature review.
Find similar papers in the chat
Make a presentation
100%