Freedom and Animal Welfare
Свобода и благополучие животных
2021-04-17
SCID: 54.1/jcps8xn3
Discuss with AI
animal captivityanimal welfarecomparative welfare datafreedom as instrumental goodfreedom as intrinsic good
Figures from the paper
Abstract (AI)
The keeping of captive animals in zoos and aquariums has long been controversial. Many take freedom to be a crucial part of animal welfare and, on these grounds, criticise all forms of animal captivity as harmful to animal welfare, regardless of their provisions. Here, we analyse what it might mean for freedom to matter to welfare, distinguishing between the role of freedom as an intrinsic good, valued for its own sake and an instrumental good, its value arising from the increased ability to provide other important resources. Too often, this debate is conducted through trading intuitions about what matters for animals. We argue for the need for the collection of comparative welfare data about wild and captive animals in order to settle the issue. Discovering more about the links between freedom and animal welfare will then allow for more empirically informed ethical decisions regarding captive animals.
Key Findings
1
Better evidence about the relationship between freedom and welfare could support more empirically informed ethical decisions about keeping animals in captivity.
2
Comparative welfare data from wild and captive animals are needed to determine how freedom affects animal welfare.
3
It argues that claims portraying all captivity as harmful to welfare cannot be settled by intuition alone, because captive conditions and welfare outcomes may differ.
4
The paper distinguishes freedom’s potential intrinsic value for animal welfare from its instrumental value through enabling access to other important resources.
Research Object
captive and wild animals, particularly animals kept in zoos and aquariums
Research Subject
the relationship between freedom and animal welfare, including freedom’s intrinsic and instrumental value and comparative welfare outcomes in captivity versus the wild
Publication Details
Publication Date
2021-04-17
Journal
Publisher
ISSN
Cited by
74
Open access PDF
Access Type
Author Information
Download PDF
Subscribe to digest