Demography and Design: Predictors of New Product Team Performance
Демография и дизайн: предикторы эффективности команд разработки новых продуктов
1992-08-01
SCID: 54.1/jdgsf8fx
Discuss with AI
external communicationfunctional diversitynew product teamsteam performancetenure diversity
Figures from the paper
Abstract (AI)
The increasing reliance on teams in organizations raises the question of how these teams should be formed. Should they be formed completely of engineers or should they include a range of specialists? Should they be made up to people who have long tenure in the organization, or those with a wide range of experience? As teams increasingly get called upon to do more complex tasks and to cross functional boundaries within the organization, conventional wisdom has suggested that teams be composed of more diverse members. This study suggests that the answer may not be so simple. Using 409 individuals from 45 new product teams in five high-technology companies, this study investigates the impact of diversity on team performance. We found that functional and tenure diversity each has its own distinct effects. The greater the functional diversity, the more team members communicated outside the team's boundaries. This communication was with a variety of groups such as marketing, manufacturing, and top management. The more the external communication, the higher the managerial ratings of innovation. Tenure diversity had its impact on internal group dynamics rather than external communications. Tenure diversity is associated with improved task work such as clarifying group goals and setting priorities. In turn, this clarity is associated with high team ratings of overall performance. Yet diversity is not solely positive. While it does produce internal processes and external communications that facilitate performance, it also directly impedes performance. That is, overall the effect of diversity on performance is negative, even though some aspects of group work are enhanced. It may be that for these teams diversity brings more creativity to problem solving and product development, but it impedes implementation because there is less capability for teamwork than there is for homogeneous teams. These research findings suggest that simply changing the structure of teams (i.e. combining representatives of diverse function and tenure) will not improve performance. The team must find a way to garner the positive process effects of diversity and to reduce the negative direct effects. At the team level, greater negotiation and conflict resolution skills may be necessary. At the organization level, the team may need to be protected from external political pressures and rewarded for team, rather than functional, outcomes.
Key Findings
1
Despite enhancing internal processes and external communication, diversity has an overall negative direct effect on team performance, potentially because it impedes implementation and teamwork.
2
Greater functional diversity increases communication across team boundaries with marketing, manufacturing, and top management, which is associated with higher managerial ratings of innovation.
3
Tenure diversity improves internal task processes, including clarifying group goals and setting priorities; these improvements are associated with higher overall team-performance ratings.
4
The findings challenge the assumption that greater team diversity is uniformly beneficial for complex, cross-functional new-product work.
5
Using data from 409 individuals across 45 new-product teams in five high-technology companies, the study finds distinct effects for functional and tenure diversity.
Research Object
New product teams in high-technology companies
Research Subject
The effects of functional and tenure diversity on team communication, internal task processes, innovation, and overall performance
Publication Details
Publication Date
1992-08-01
Journal
Publisher
ISSN
Cited by
1798
Access Type
Author Information
Download PDF
Subscribe to digest