Why encouraging more people to become entrepreneurs is bad public policy

Почему поощрение большего числа людей к занятию предпринимательством является неэффективной государственной политикой
Scott Shane
2009-06-08

economic growthentrepreneurship policyhigh-growth companiesjob creationstart-up companies
Policy makers often think that creating more start-up companies will transform depressed economic regions, generate innovation, and create jobs. This belief is flawed because the typical start-up is not innovative, creates few jobs, and generates little wealth. Getting economic growth and jobs creation from entrepreneurs is not a numbers game. It is about encouraging the formation of high quality, high growth companies. Policy makers should stop subsidizing the formation of the typical start-up and focus on the subset of businesses with growth potential. While government officials will not be able to “pick winners,” they can identify start-ups with a low probability of generating jobs and enhancing economic growth. By eliminating incentives to create these low probability companies, policy makers can improve the average performance of new businesses.
1
Although policymakers cannot reliably pick winners, they can identify and eliminate incentives for start-ups with a low probability of generating jobs or economic growth.
2
Entrepreneurship-driven economic growth depends on forming a smaller subset of high-quality, high-growth companies rather than maximizing the number of start-ups.
3
Policies subsidizing typical start-up formation are unlikely to produce substantial innovation, employment, or wealth creation.
4
Removing support for low-potential businesses could improve the average performance of newly formed companies.
5
The typical start-up is not innovative, creates few jobs, and generates little wealth, challenging the assumption that more start-ups automatically drive regional growth.

start-up companies and new businesses

the relationship between start-up quality and economic outcomes, including innovation, job creation, wealth generation, and the effectiveness of entrepreneurship subsidies

Publication Details
Publication Date
2009-06-08
Journal
Publisher
ISSN
Access Type
Author Information
Authors
Scott Shane
Explore further
Open the scid.ai AI chat with a ready-made request: it will find papers on a similar topic and help build a literature review.
Find similar papers in the chat
Make a presentation
100%