Rhetorical structure of research paper introductions in computer science: a comparative analysis
Риторическая структура введений научных статей в информатике: сравнительный анализ
2023-10-02
SCID: 54.1/k66w7mvm
Discuss with AI
computer sciencecreate-a-research-space (CARS) modelcross-cultural variationresearch paper introductionsrhetorical structure
Figures from the paper
Abstract (AI)
Research paper introductions are considered challenging, especially for academic writers whose native language is different from English. Despite the large interest in the rhetorical organization of research papers across various disciplines and cultures, little is known about the structural patterns used by Russian authors in English-language research paper introductions in Computer Science as one of the fastest growing scientific fields. To fill the gap, this paper investigates the ways Russian academic writers organize their introductions as compared to the norms of the international scientific community where English is the acknowledged lingua franca. The purpose of this study is to identify discrepancies between the approaches to structuring computer science introductions generated in the English language by Russian and Anglophone authors. Drawing evidence from 43 research papers published in highly ranked Russian and Anglophone journals in Computer Science, it addresses the main features specific to research paper introductions in this field and analyzes how rhetorical moves are realized linguistically by both native and non-native academic writers based on the create-a-research-space (CARS) model. The results of the qualitative study show that Russian authors make use of fewer strategies than native English writers; moreover, the former tend to avoid the ‘establishing a niche’ move, which is considered obligatory in the structure of a research paper introduction. The paper adds to the exploration of cross-cultural variations in academic writing.
Key Findings
1
Dataset comprises 43 research papers from highly ranked Russian and Anglophone Computer Science journals.
2
Findings highlight cross-cultural variations in academic writing and structural discrepancies between Russian and international norms.
3
Russian authors tend to avoid the 'establishing a niche' move, considered obligatory in research paper introductions.
4
Russian authors use fewer rhetorical strategies in introductions than native English writers.
5
Study compares rhetorical organization of English-language Computer Science introductions by Russian and Anglophone authors using the CARS model.
Research Object
Research paper introductions in Computer Science written in English by Russian and Anglophone authors
Research Subject
Comparative rhetorical structure and realization of rhetorical moves (based on the CARS model), including frequency of strategies and occurrence/avoidance of the 'establishing a niche' move
Publication Details
Publication Date
2023-10-02
Journal
Publisher
ISSN
Cited by
6
Open access PDF
Access Type
Author Information
Download PDF
Subscribe to digest