From planetary to societal boundaries: an argument for collectively defined self-limitation

От планетарных к социальным границам: аргумент в пользу коллективно определяемого самоограничения
Ulrich Brand, Barbara Muraca, Éric Pineault, Marlyne Sahakian, Anke Schaffartzik, Andreas Novy, Christoph Streissler, Helmut Haberl, Viviana Asara, Kristina Dietz, Miriam Lang, Ashish Kothari, Tone Smith, Clive L. Spash, Alina Brad, Mélanie Pichler, Christina M. Plank, Giorgos Velegrakis, Thomas Jähn, Angela V. Carter, Qingzhi Huan, Giorgos Kallis, Joan Martínez Alier, Gabriel Riva, Vishwas Satgar, Emiliano Terán Mantovani, Michelle Williams, Markus Wissen, Christoph Görg
2021-01-01

capitalist expansionary dynamicscollective self-limitationplanetary boundariessocial-ecological transformationsocietal boundaries
The planetary boundaries concept has profoundly changed the vocabulary and representation of global environmental issues. We bring a critical social science perspective to this framework through the notion of societal boundaries and aim to provide a more nuanced understanding of the social nature of thresholds. We start by highlighting the strengths and weaknesses of planetary boundaries from a social science perspective. We then focus on capitalist societies as a heuristic for discussing the expansionary dynamics, power relations, and lock-ins of modern societies that impel highly unsustainable societal relations with nature. While formulating societal boundaries implies a controversial process ‒ based on normative judgments, ethical concerns, and socio-political struggles ‒ it has the potential to offer guidelines for a just, social-ecological transformation. Collective autonomy and the politics of self-limitation are key elements of societal boundaries and are linked to important proposals and pluriverse experiences to integrate well-being and boundaries. The role of the state and propositions for radical alternative approaches to well-being have particular importance. We conclude with reflections on social freedom, defined as the right not to live at others’ expense. Toward the aim of defining boundaries through transdisciplinary and democratic processes, we seek to open a dialogue on these issues.
1
Capitalist societies exhibit expansionary dynamics, power relations, and lock-ins that drive highly unsustainable relations with nature, motivating the need for societal boundaries.
2
Collective autonomy and politics of self-limitation are central to societal boundaries and can guide a just social-ecological transformation integrating well-being and ecological limits.
3
Defining societal boundaries requires transdisciplinary, democratic processes emphasizing the state's role, radical well-being approaches, and the principle of social freedom as not living at others' expense.
4
Introducing 'societal boundaries' provides a nuanced, socially grounded understanding of environmental thresholds linked to norms, ethics, and political struggles.
5
Planetary boundaries concept reshaped discourse on global environmental issues but has social-science limitations regarding the social nature of thresholds.

Societal boundaries as an extension of the planetary boundaries framework in capitalist societies

The social nature, normative framing, collective self-limitation and political dimensions (power relations, expansionary dynamics, state role) of defining and implementing societal boundaries to guide just social-ecological transformation

Publication Details
Publication Date
2021-01-01
Journal
Sustainability Science Practice and Policy
Publisher
Taylor & Francis
ISSN
1548-7733
Cited by
370
Access Type
Author Information
Authors
Ulrich Brand
Barbara Muraca
Éric Pineault
Marlyne Sahakian
Anke Schaffartzik
Andreas Novy
Christoph Streissler
Helmut Haberl
Viviana Asara
Kristina Dietz
Miriam Lang
Ashish Kothari
Tone Smith
Clive L. Spash
Alina Brad
Mélanie Pichler
Christina M. Plank
Giorgos Velegrakis
Thomas Jähn
Angela V. Carter
Qingzhi Huan
Giorgos Kallis
Joan Martínez Alier
Gabriel Riva
Vishwas Satgar
Emiliano Terán Mantovani
Michelle Williams
Markus Wissen
Christoph Görg
Explore further
Open the scid.ai AI chat with a ready-made request: it will find papers on a similar topic and help build a literature review.
Find similar papers in the chat →
Make a presentation
100%