A Systematic Review of Medication Adherence Thresholds Dependent of Clinical Outcomes
Систематический обзор пороговых значений приверженности к лекарственной терапии в зависимости от клинических исходов
2018-11-20
SCID: 54.1/kstqh94e
Discuss with AI
Medication Possession RatioProportion of Days Coveredchronic diseasesclinical outcomesmedication adherence thresholds
Figures from the paper
Abstract (AI)
Background: In pharmacotherapy, the achievement of a target clinical outcome requires a certain level of medication intake or adherence. Based on Haynes’s early empirical definition of sufficient adherence to antihypertensive medications as taking ≥80% of medication, many researchers used this threshold to distinguish adherent from non-adherent patients. However, we propose that different diseases, medications and patient’s characteristics influence the threshold of the adherence rate above which the clinical outcome is satisfactory. Moreover, the assessment of adherence and clinical outcomes may differ greatly and should be taken into consideration. We aimed at investigating medication adherence thresholds in relation to clinical outcomes. Method: We searched for studies that determined the relationship between adherence rates and clinical outcomes in the databases PubMed, Embase® and Web of Science™ until December 2017, limited to English-language. Our outcome measure was any threshold value of adherence. Inclusion criteria were 1) any measurement of medication adherence; 2) any assessment of clinical outcomes 3) any method to define medication adherence thresholds in relation to clinical outcomes. Two authors independently screened titles and abstracts for relevance, reviewed full-texts, and extracted items. The results of the included studies are presented qualitatively. Result: We analyzed six articles that assessed clinical outcomes linked to adherence rates in seven chronic disease states. Medication adherence was measured with Medication Possession Ratio (MPR, n = 3), Proportion of Days Covered (PDC, n = 1), both (n = 1), or Medication Event Monitoring System (MEMS). Clinical outcomes were event free episodes, hospitalization, cortisone use, reported symptoms and reduction of lipid levels. To find the relationship between the targeted clinical outcome and adherence rates, three studies applied logistic regression and three used survival analysis. Five studies defined adherence thresholds between 46% and 92%. One study confirmed the 80% threshold as valid to distinguish adherent from non-adherent patients. Conclusion: The analyzed studies were highly heterogeneous, predominantly concerning methods of calculating adherence. We could not compare studies quantitatively, mostly because adherence rates could not be standardized. Therefore, we cannot reject or confirm the validity of the historical 80% threshold. Nevertheless, the 80% threshold was clearly questioned as a general standard.
Key Findings
1
A systematic search through December 2017 identified only six eligible studies examining adherence thresholds linked to clinical outcomes across seven chronic disease states.
2
Studies measured adherence using MPR, PDC, combined MPR/PDC, or MEMS, while outcomes included event-free episodes, hospitalization, cortisone use, symptoms, and lipid-level reduction.
3
The limited and heterogeneous evidence indicates that adherence thresholds should be determined in relation to specific clinical outcomes rather than applying a fixed universal cutoff.
4
The review challenges the universal 80% adherence threshold, arguing that clinically meaningful thresholds vary by disease, medication, patient characteristics, and outcome assessment.
5
Three studies used logistic regression and three used survival analysis to relate adherence rates to clinical outcomes.
Research Object
Medication adherence in pharmacotherapy across chronic diseases and treatments
Research Subject
Adherence-rate thresholds associated with satisfactory clinical outcomes
Publication Details
Publication Date
2018-11-20
Journal
Publisher
ISSN
Open access PDF
Access Type
Author Information
Download PDF
Subscribe to digest