Resilience Training Programs with Police Forces: A Systematic Review

Программы подготовки по развитию стрессоустойчивости для сотрудников полиции: систематический обзор
Ana Filipa Moreno, Maria Karanika‐Murray, Patrícia Batista, Rowena Hill, S. Rubiol Vilalta, Patrícia Oliveira‐Silva
2024-01-18

mindfulness-based interventionsneurobiological interventionspolice occupational stresspolice resilience trainingsystematic review
Abstract Through the course of their career, it is expected that police officers are exposed to stressful and emotionally challenging environments, which, combined with well-known organizational and occupational stressors, makes this professional class vulnerable to several psychological and medical conditions. In recent years, there has been a growing interest in developing intervention programs that seek to minimize the impact of the changing nature of police work within a changing society and promote skills that enable police officers to deal more effectively with the current and future challenges. Therefore, the aim of this review is to systematize resilience training intervention programs and characterize their format, content, and efficacy. For that purpose, we searched four databases for resilience programs delivered to the police. We reached a final sample of 32 articles from a total of 550 published studies. The articles considered were divided into three main groups: mindfulness-based resilience interventions (n = 13), neurobiological-based resilience interventions (n = 13), and other resilience training interventions that did not fit in the previous categories (n = 6). There was much inter-intervention variability, mainly concerning their structure and approach. However, the intervention programs were relatively uniform in the topics covered, such as psychoeducation, police scenario simulation, and debriefing. Nonetheless, most studies found positive outcomes on the variables of interest, predominantly clinical and performance indicators (e.g., stress, anxiety, decision-making). Subsequent research endeavors could aim to determine the most reliable measure outcome measures for resilience variables and intervention efficacy, as alongside identifying pivotal occupational factors crucial to a robust and impactful resilience intervention.
1
Future research should establish reliable resilience and efficacy measures and identify occupational factors essential for effective interventions.
2
Interventions comprised mindfulness-based programs (n=13), neurobiological-based programs (n=13), and other resilience training approaches (n=6).
3
Most studies reported positive effects on clinical and performance outcomes, particularly stress, anxiety, and decision-making.
4
Programs varied substantially in structure and approach but commonly included psychoeducation, police-scenario simulation, and debriefing.
5
The systematic review identified 32 studies of police resilience training programs from 550 screened publications across four databases.

Resilience training intervention programs delivered to police forces and police officers

The format, content, and efficacy of resilience training interventions, including their effects on police officers’ psychological and performance outcomes

Publication Details
Publication Date
2024-01-18
Journal
Publisher
ISSN
Cited by
26
Access Type
Author Information
Authors
Ana Filipa Moreno
Maria Karanika‐Murray
Patrícia Batista
Rowena Hill
S. Rubiol Vilalta
Patrícia Oliveira‐Silva
Explore further
Open the scid.ai AI chat with a ready-made request: it will find papers on a similar topic and help build a literature review.
Find similar papers in the chat
Make a presentation
100%