Lessons from first generation biofuels and implications for the sustainability appraisal of second generation biofuels

Уроки, извлечённые из использования биотоплива первого поколения, и их значение для оценки устойчивости биотоплива второго поколения
Sujatha Raman, Alison Mohr
2013-09-10

Science and Technology Studiesbioenergy policyfirst-generation biofuel controversysecond-generation biofuelssustainability appraisal
AIMS: The emergence of second generation (2G) biofuels is widely seen as a sustainable response to the increasing controversy surrounding the first generation (1G). Yet, sustainability credentials of 2G biofuels are also being questioned. Drawing on work in Science and Technology Studies, we argue that controversies help focus attention on key, often value-related questions that need to be posed to address broader societal concerns. This paper examines lessons drawn from the 1G controversy to assess implications for the sustainability appraisal of 2G biofuels. SCOPE: We present an overview of key 1G sustainability challenges, assess their relevance for 2G, and highlight the challenges for policy in managing the transition. We address limitations of existing sustainability assessments by exploring where challenges might emerge across the whole system of bioenergy and the wider context of the social system in which bioenergy research and policy are done. CONCLUSIONS: Key lessons arising from 1G are potentially relevant to the sustainability appraisal of 2G biofuels depending on the particular circumstances or conditions under which 2G is introduced. We conclude that sustainability challenges commonly categorised as either economic, environmental or social are, in reality, more complexly interconnected (so that an artificial separation of these categories is problematic).
1
Economic, environmental, and social sustainability challenges are interconnected, making separate analytical categories potentially misleading.
2
Existing assessments are limited because sustainability challenges can emerge across the entire bioenergy system and its wider social, research, and policy context.
3
Managing the transition to second-generation biofuels presents policy challenges that require attention to broader societal concerns and contextual conditions.
4
Many sustainability challenges identified for first-generation biofuels may also affect second-generation biofuels, depending on the conditions of their introduction.
5
The controversy surrounding first-generation biofuels highlights value-related questions that should inform sustainability appraisal of second-generation biofuels.

second generation (2G) biofuels and their introduction within the broader bioenergy and social system

sustainability challenges and the interconnections among economic, environmental, and social dimensions relevant to assessing 2G biofuels, including lessons from 1G controversies

Publication Details
Publication Date
2013-09-10
Journal
Publisher
ISSN
Cited by
492
Access Type
Author Information
Authors
Sujatha Raman
Alison Mohr
Explore further
Open the scid.ai AI chat with a ready-made request: it will find papers on a similar topic and help build a literature review.
Find similar papers in the chat →
Make a presentation
100%